返回资讯中心
外部精选
软件工程
#开发者实时流

From Method to Paid Skill: Part 3

This is Part 3 in a five-part series about how Rob and I are building a paid skill business.

Hacker News 最新gerroo2026/10/20 · 26 天前17 分钟阅读

以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。

Eren Suner

Oct 20, 2026

Share

This is Part 3 in a five-part series about how Rob and I are building a paid skill business.

Rob writes The Physics of Startups to help founders find product-market fit. He also wrote PULL and has a paid skill.

A paid skill is a guide that helps AI agents do a task like an expert. Skillfully helps authors sell these guides and rapidly improve them.

Since doing the interviews in the last article, we noticed that we still didn’t really know what we were selling. We had a skill people were using, but we also had to figure out what a skill business was supposed to look like.

I’d also been posting about paid skills on Reddit, where people kept telling me they would never pay a recurring amount for one. We had to figure out what it was that we were selling and why people would pay for it.

In this article I’ll go through how we figured this out with Rob, including what the product should do, how to get people started with it and how to price it.

By now, Rob had decided to build a website for his skill. That brought an unnerving question with it:

Is the promise “Consult an AI version of Rob Snyder”? Or “Run sales like Rob Snyder”?

More generally: are people buying a way to ask an AI version of an expert questions, or a way to do a task like that expert?

Before we did, I wanted to look at the other ways experts share and sell their knowledge. What does an audience member want from a podcast, a book, a course, or a community?

I tried to describe each one in a sentence.

A podcast has an interesting twist: you get to listen to your topic guy’s subtopic guy. Instead of listening to Huberman talk about sleep, you can listen to him interview a sleep expert.

A blog, like Paul Graham’s essays or A Smart Bear, lets you follow someone’s thinking and try their way of doing things. The hope is that you’ll get results like theirs, or like the people they’ve helped.

Courses have their own distinctions. Maven and Udemy are marketplaces. Broadly, Maven is for when your employer is paying; Udemy is for when you are. Kajabi gives the author tools to make and sell a course, so the author handles distribution.

Underneath all these formats is the same urge:

“Understand the expert’s approach to a topic so I can replicate what they do and get similar results.”

Understand Huberman’s approach to brain health so I can do what he would do in my situation—say, when I can’t sleep—and sleep better.

Understand Paul Graham’s approach to startups so I can do what he would do with Skillfully and make it successful.

Even Napoleon: study earlier generals’ campaigns in Italy, repeat what worked, avoid their mistakes, and get results. Apparently, those earlier generals weren’t expert enough.

Cool. Now look at the second half of that sentence: “so I can replicate what they do and get similar results.”

“Get better results at a task by having my AI use an expert’s method.”

For someone in Rob’s audience: “Get better results at sales by having my AI use Rob’s method.”

Of course, sales is made up of smaller tasks. Rob’s method is a collection of frameworks and beliefs for doing those tasks.

There’s a need for structure underneath this. I usually look for a method when I’m unsure how to do a task. I’m even less confident asking my AI to do it when I can’t judge whether its answer is any good.

A skill gives that work a structure: the expert’s way of doing it.

The interviews from Part 2 gave us a clearer picture of what people wanted. Now we had to turn those wants into changes to the skill.

I like a simple table for this: what the audience wants on one side, what needs to change on the other.

The wants are drawn from the Part 2 interviews; the right column translates them into changes to make.

Those requests fall into three groups: do, teach, and review.

For LinkedIn outreach, the agent might do the work. For a sales call, it might review what happened and teach the founder how to run the next one better.

Onboarding

They say onboarding is the most important feature of your product. The same is true for skills.

During onboarding, you have the most users. Some will drop off afterward. This is your one shot at turning them into avid skill users.

A skill needs two separate onboardings: one for the user and one for the agent.

Show the user what they can now ask their agent to do.

A video or a web page can help. It will need updates as the skill evolves.

With Rob’s skill, we saw that people could install it and still not know what to do next. So he put examples of what it could do, such as call reviews, on his website.

Set up the workspace so the agent can do the work.

Typically, an agent has access to a file system where it can read, write, list, and create files. I suggest having it set up a template directory, or copy one directly from your skill folder.

With Rob’s skill, the agent copies over a template dashboard and populates it with real company data at regular intervals.

These two onboardings should happen together. While the user learns what to ask, the agent sets up the workspace.

The agent presents prewritten onboarding text. The user types “continue,” and the agent directs them to a video.

The user watches the video while the agent sets up its workspace.

The user returns to a ready workspace, or waits for setup to finish.

The agent suggests one concrete action to help the user reach their goal.

Pricing

Because it was still early, Rob and I initially settled on:

Skills should be priced at $50–$100/month for personal use and $100–$200/month per seat for business use. The right price depends on what the skill does.

With Rob’s skill, no one seems price-sensitive. When you’re selling something worth $50,000 a year, paying $50 or $100 a month for a skill is a no-brainer if it helps you sell more effectively.

Sometimes a founder or senior executive buys a skill, uses it, is amazed by it, and then buys it for the whole team. We’ve seen this happen twice out of 20 clients.

There are two other ways to structure pricing.

Put different features in different plans.

For example, Rob’s sales call review could cost $25/month. To use deal reviews, you’d upgrade to “Rob Premium Plus” for $50/month.

The cheaper feature should naturally lead to the paid upgrade. Reviewing one call can lead someone to want a review of the whole deal.

Charge according to how much someone uses the skill.

For example: $25/month for the first 10 calls, then $20 for each additional 10 calls. Or offer an unlimited plan for $250/month.

My hunch is that the client service norms of consulting and other high-ticket professional services will give us a useful blueprint for designing agent skills.

Hey, thanks for reading this article! Next up: Part 4.

I want your feedback! Email me at eren [at] skillfully [dot] sh.

Skillfully is accepting author applications! Apply here.

正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。

打开原文
去社区讨论 →