
Tim O'Reilly – The New Knowledge Artifacts of the AI Economy
The New Knowledge Artifacts of the AI Economy
以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。
Translate
The New Knowledge Artifacts of the AI Economy
Every technology revolution creates new knowledge artifacts that are valuable and worth sharing.
O'Reilly and Tim O'Reilly
Nov 05, 2026
5
2
1
Share
At our recent Foo Camp, a number of people said something like, “I don’t want someone else’s code any more. I may have my agent take a look at it, but I want to extract just the parts that I want, and may rewrite even those in Rust. It’s just too easy to create just the code that I want.”
This topic was hot enough that Jesse Vincent held an entire session about it. I did not attend, but Jesse gave me a report from his Plaude AI notetaker. Here’s a relevant section of the summary:
Several participants argue that software development’s primary artifact may be shifting from executable code toward natural-language prompts, generation processes, and developer skills. One speaker compares Python to assembly language, suggesting that writing conventional code may become optional as natural-language generation takes precedence. Another argues that open source can survive such a transition because its core values—peer production, capacity building, and shared specifications—do not depend on who or what writes the code.
At the same time, Jesse warns that maintainers are overwhelmed by floods of uninvited, automated, and often low-quality contributions. Participants say that traditional milestones such as pull requests, repositories, and conferences have helped contributors connect and gain recognition; as AI makes code replication easier, communities may need new ways to acknowledge participation and create paths for future developers. Some community interaction has moved to spaces such as Discord and direct messages, but structured opportunities are still needed.
Scientific computing raises particular concerns. One panelist warns that AI-generated forks and agent attacks could threaten carefully verified foundations such as NumPy and SciPy. Scientific systems depend on battle-tested libraries and reproducibility, so thousands of unreviewed alternatives could undermine reliability. Participants suggest bridging traditional open-source communities and modern AI development, which currently may use different tools and artifacts.
Other proposals include treating code as “liquid” and focusing open-source governance on durable infrastructure and specifications; maintaining agent storage independently of ephemeral container lifecycles; and using corporate compliance and safety-monitoring architectures to aggregate organizational traces.
These are important observations, all pointing in the same direction: AI is transforming the mechanisms and the artifacts of software development. For an increasing number of use cases, the software source code itself may no longer be the most important shareable knowledge artifact. This isn’t a new phenomenon. Every major change in technology calls for new mechanisms, new artifacts, and new institutions.
Originally, software developers mostly distributed binaries, then open source developers made sharing source code the norm. Now we need to distribute and share something else: context and patterns for generating code on the fly. Knowledge is being unbundled and can be shared in new forms. A repo may now serve merely as a source of context for solving the exact problem I have, rather than the bundle of problems that the original developer(s) encoded into their library or packaged solution. Some people will keep their context and patterns private, either because they see proprietary advantage in keeping them to themselves or because they are too busy or too lazy to share. But part of the problem is that we haven’t yet figured out what needs to be shared!
The challenge for the software development community is to identify the new knowledge artifacts of the AI economy, and to build new mechanisms and incentives for sharing them.
We’ve all had the experience of seeing a bespoke agentically generated app, wanting something similar, and wishing we could ask for a starting point so we didn’t have to vibe code an equivalent from scratch, with all the attention, false starts, and token costs that comes with that. Even in a world where software is generated by agents, it’s still not costless, and most of us like a good place to start.
Of course, this won’t be all software. There are lots of areas where “sort of alike” software is a recipe for disaster. Imagine a sales and marketing group where everyone had their own vibe-coded CRM tools, with different metrics and capabilities. This is not good. So there is still a place for big SaaS applications, distributed binary software, and distributed source code. You pick the hat to fit the head. But there’s also a need for something new.
The purpose of this article is to start a conversation about exactly what it is that developers should be preserving, sharing, and building on from others, and what mechanisms are still missing to make that virtuous circle work more effectively. I can’t see into the future; I can only speculate. So, as is often the case, I take a historical view. The poet W. S. Merwin wrote, “We are the echo of the future.” I have found that using history to frame the present can be a productive way to get our minds going in the right direction.
Note that while this article focuses on software development, the questions I’m asking here apply to virtually every field. Let me know if you have insights from your work in any area touched by AI.
The ease with which LLMs can generate code is paradoxically getting people to focus too much on how easy it is not to produce code. That may be blinding us to the fact that code itself is being displaced as a valuable, tradeable, shareable knowledge artifact. Maybe “displaced” is too strong a word. Different species of value overlap for a long time. Eventually, though, old ones fade and new ones become dominant. This has happened before. Every technology revolution draws not only on new mechanisms but also creates new valuable knowledge artifacts. I talked about this in my recent short keynote at AGNTCon + MCPCon.
The open source revolution depended in part on mechanisms like modular design and source code control, even more than it depended on free software licenses. It birthed new coordinating institutions like GitHub. But it also created a valuable new class of knowledge artifact in the form of the source code repo, and subsidiary valuable artifacts like commit history and reputation. A developer’s public repos became a kind of résumé, and a project’s commit log became a record of who had done what, and how well. This replaced a previous world where binaries were the tradeable objects of the software economy. Microsoft’s fortune was built on selling licenses to binaries, and to anyone who measured the software economy in licenses sold, free software looked like value being destroyed. (Steve Ballmer called GPL’d free software “a cancer” and Microsoft VP Jim Allchin called it “an intellectual property destroyer.”)
There were two ways that I like to think about the effects of open source software. First, value that was based on scarcity was replaced by value that was created by abundance. Back in 1975, Steve Baer described this as “the clothesline paradox,” explaining that when you put your clothes in the dryer, the energy you use is measured and counted, but when you hang your clothes on the line, it is ignored by accounting, despite doing the same job. Open source software was like sunshine, free for the taking, and its value unmeasured. Everyone compared the revenue of free software companies like Red Hat and MySQL to the vastly larger revenues of proprietary software companies like Microsoft and Oracle, noted the fact that they hadn’t even survived as independent companies, and concluded that open source was a less effective business model because its creators captured less of the value. They missed the point that far more value had been created than had been captured. Open source went on to power most of the internet economy, with the value captured by other means than selling the software itself.
Some people might think of this as a kind of failure, but they would be wrong. It is the system working exactly as its creators intended. I remember talking with Bob Scheifler, one of the creators of the X Window System, about whether it was OK that we were building commercial versions of their documentation. He told me that was exactly what he had intended. They put things out with a very permissive license precisely because they wanted others to build on top of them. I remember him saying “We want to raise the floor.” The creators of Berkeley Unix, Apache, and others felt exactly the same way. They didn’t want to win the existing game. They wanted to play a different game.
And they succeeded, big time. As Clayton Christensen noted in 2004, when one thing becomes a commodity, modular and fungible, something else (usually something adjacent) becomes valuable. He called this “The Law of Conservation of Attractive Profits.” At about the same time, I had stumbled onto this principle in explaining the implications of open source software in giving rise to the new paradigm that I was shortly to start calling Web 2.0. Clay and I first bonded when we gave our respective keynotes about essentially the same thing at the 2004 Open Source Business Conference. I later wrote about the conjunction of our respective ideas in a piece called “The Open Source Paradigm Shift.”
New artifacts are often the first visible sign of this value transition. You can see this at work in the evolution of the web. The web was born from the new mechanism of internet-enabled hypertext via HTTP, HTML, and the modular, replaceable software (the web browser and the web server) that made it useful.
At first, the new valuable knowledge artifact was the website with its domain name, associated URLs, and HTML-formatted web pages. DNS was the coordinating institution. People paid fortunes for domain names on the premise that the site was the thing that mattered. And it did matter, and still does. But less than it used to. Over time, Google became the new coordinating institution, and its ability to point deep within websites made the web page, not just the site itself, a valuable knowledge artifact. Social media made “posts” and short-form video into other knowledge artifacts. New kinds of value creation and value capture tumbled out of that unbundling. Packaged software was displaced as the key monetizable artifact and replaced by web applications, which were information- and software-based frontends to vast backend databases.
The click became a new and incredibly valuable knowledge artifact, the unit in which attention and intent were measured, and then priced. First pay per click advertising (Google), then engagement maxing (social media) became the basis of vast fortunes. The people who notice the new artifacts early, while everyone else is still focused on the old ones, then invent new business models based on them, often play a bigger game than those who were still trying to play by the new rules.
When I summed up these ideas in “What Is Web 2.0” in 2005, I talked about the key principles being “harnessing collective intelligence,” “software above the level of a single device,” and “data as the next Intel Inside.” (That is, the next valuable source of lock-in.) The companies that survived the dot-com bust were the ones that understood that the data their users generated through their activity on the internet was the asset that mattered, not just the software that served it. That was an argument about a new knowledge artifact, though I didn’t use those words at the time. PageRank understood that a link was a vote, and a new mechanism to improve organic search birthed new dimensions of the internet economy. Links were bought, sold, and gamed accordingly. SEO (both “wh
正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。