Solvej Balle's Philosophy of Time
Peter Dreher, Tag um Tag guter Tag (Day by Day Good Day) Nr. 2060; Nr. 2253; Nr. 2345; Nr. 2454, 2007–2009. Photograph courtesy Huxley Parlour. © 2026 Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn
以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。
Peter Dreher, Tag um Tag guter Tag (Day by Day Good Day) Nr. 2060; Nr. 2253; Nr. 2345; Nr. 2454, 2007–2009. Photograph courtesy Huxley Parlour. © 2026 Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn
More than two millennia after the fact, we still talk about that time Archimedes solved a mathematical problem in the bath. Descending into a public bathing pool and watching it overflow, he realized he could calculate the volume of any irregular solid by immersing it in a container filled with water: the object’s volume would be equal to the volume of water it displaced. Archimedes hit upon this method to solve a practical problem. The king of Syracuse had asked him to find out whether a golden crown was made of real gold or an alloy of cheaper metals. By measuring the crown’s volume, Archimedes could determine its density and compare it with a piece of true gold. He leaped out of the pool and ran home naked, shouting “Eureka, Eureka!”—I’ve found it!
The Danish author Solvej Balle alludes to this story of displacement and discovery in the title of her seven-part novel, On the Calculation of Volume (Om udregning af rumfang). Published in installments—six books so far in Danish, four translated into English—this work has garnered Balle an International Booker nomination, a place on the National Book Award longlist, and a cult following. It records a young woman’s experience of being stuck in a time loop where the same day continuously repeats itself. Tara Selter and her husband, Thomas, used to share a contented life as antiquarian booksellers in a village in northern France. All that changes for Tara on a solo book-buying trip to Paris. Suddenly, for no apparent reason, November 18 recurs once, then twice, then again and again. Everyone else—including Thomas—seems to be living this day for the first time. By the end of the fourth book, it is November 18 #3637: nearly ten years on, in old time.
“My time is a container,” Tara writes in her diary, which comprises the book we’re reading. “It is a day one can step into. Again and again. Not a stream which one can only dip into once.…Every day I lower my body into the eighteenth of November. I move around but nothing runs over the edge.” Here Balle layers the Archimedean metaphor with Heraclitus’s ancient teaching that one cannot step into the same river twice. Displaced in time, Tara must reckon with a world that fits no familiar pattern—a scientific task, and also a philosophical project. The original calculation of volume, after all, was linked to a calculation of value, and to a question about authenticity: the ideal of our present age and a leitmotif of existentialism. It’s not incidental that the irregular solid in Archimedes’ eureka moment was his own body. Balle is conducting a first-person experiment about human existence, testing its ethical and metaphysical dimensions.
This elaborately reflexive novel, in which thought is plot, provokes us to consider what knowledge really is.
It is as a philosophical novel that On the Calculation of Volume merits attention and acclaim. This is a slippery genre, since most works of literature explore broadly philosophical themes. But certain novels do so with special directness and, moreover, pursue questions about philosophy’s methods and scope. Balle’s novel is philosophical in this robust sense. Its range is ambitious, encompassing all three of the questions that, according to Immanuel Kant, comprise philosophy’s fundamental concerns: What can I know? What must I do? What may I hope?
Balle’s own academic training has been nontraditional, unfurling over many years: she took occasional philosophy classes in her twenties (in Paris, then at Cornell) and later earned a bachelor’s and a master’s degree in the subject in Denmark. She has written across genres—a book on aesthetics, a memoir that incorporates social criticism, a quartet of philosophical parables—and her work testifies to an intense interest in how philosophy arises from the experience of living. While trained philosophers (like me) will notice the influence of various thinkers and ideas throughout On the Calculation of Volume, no specialist knowledge is required to join in the philosophical inquiry staged by the novel. Tara’s predicament is at once wildly implausible and relatable: the experience of being marooned in one’s own consciousness is familiar to us all. So is the fact that each day involves some combination of sameness and difference, and that each human life holds some combination of knowing and not-knowing. Our lifetimes, too, tend to be divided into “befores” and “afters”: perhaps by the death of a parent or the birth of a child; by a war or a regime change; by a pandemic or an ecological disaster. All selves are liable to be displaced.
So although Tara’s time loop requires a deep and sudden plunge into metaphysics, it is also a reminder that we are already swimming in these waters. This elaborately reflexive novel, in which thought is plot, provokes us to consider what knowledge really is—and what methods might achieve it. Is philosophy, in particular, an academic discipline, with boundaries maintained by certain institutional practices and norms, or is it something more amorphous, more broadly human, more anarchic, more quotidian, more artistic? Is it done alone in one’s head, as in Descartes’s Meditations? Or together in conversation, as in Plato’s Symposium? Are we right to hope that theorizing and debating will help us to act well? What if all this thinking distracts us from acting at all?
in her programmatic 1946 essay “Literature and Metaphysics,” Simone de Beauvoir reclassified metaphysics as a “situation,” an “attitude,” and an “experience.” “One does not ‘do’ metaphysics as one ‘does’ mathematics or physics,” she argued. “In reality, ‘to do’ metaphysics is ‘to be’ metaphysical.” Beauvoir distinguished “two divergent fashions” of making this experience explicit: theoretical treatises and fiction. The choice between these genres turns on a question that runs through Balle’s work: What does philosophy have to do with universities?
One treatise that looms especially large behind her novel is Martin Heidegger’s Being and Time, a landmark of twentieth-century existentialism that attempts to explicate human “temporality.” In her diary, Tara reckons with the same experiences that Heidegger analyzes in this daunting tome: recollecting the past, anticipating the future, having a mood, embarking on projects, becoming absorbed into a social milieu. Yet Being and Time is a careerist book, written according to an academic template and designed to secure its author a university job—and Balle challenges this “fashion” of philosophizing. In volume three, Tara wanders into a university lecture “about the role of philosophy in the world.” The elderly lecturer’s words sound a little slurred: one of his teeth has come loose, and it falls out while he’s speaking. As Balle explains—somewhat unnecessarily—this incident illustrates the “toothlessness” of academic philosophy.
In her aversion to institutional theorizing, and in choosing fiction over the treatise, Balle takes a path marked out by Denmark’s best-known philosopher, Søren Kierkegaard, for whom philosophy was never a ready-made body of knowledge or system of concepts but a profoundly human art that could only be meaningfully practiced in the first person. Kierkegaard’s writing sought to awaken readers to this practice so they could examine and question (and perhaps discover) themselves. His experimental, intensely literary works emulate the playful and duplicitous style of his hero, Socrates, who philosophized not in lecture halls but on the streets. They performatively disdain academic conventions—sometimes directly, through satire, or else by defying summary and explanation, the trusted tools of the professorial trade. Usually voiced by some fictional “I,” they channel Kierkegaard’s own experiences and juggle multiple genres: letter, diary, parable, pastiche. His 1843 novella Repetition seems especially pertinent to Balle’s project: it, too, enacts an inquiry into repetition—and its effect on identity—in narrative form. Taking as its starting point the ancient debate on identity and flux ignited by Heraclitus, Repetition asks how it is possible to stay true to oneself under radically changing circumstances.
Time becomes both form and subject matter, both “container” and content.
Balle’s own fiction fuses two narrative forms, the parable and the diary, to pursue some similar philosophical aims. The time loop evokes biblical themes of fall and exile (Tara feels she has “fallen out of the world”) while echoing modern parables such as Kafka’s Metamorphosis and Camus’s Myth of Sisyphus. The diary form, meanwhile, accentuates subjectivity. In her seclusion, a diarist occupies a place of both privileged observation and intensified alienation. Tara’s deadpan first-person narration recalls the mid-century estrangement fictionalized by Camus, Sartre, Beckett, and Beauvoir herself.
A diary is, of course, a literary form explicitly indexed to quotidian time. By altering the very concept of dailiness, Balle addresses a methodological problem common to both philosophy and art: how to bring into view something as ubiquitous as time, which the muffling effects of habit make hard to perceive, much less understand. Marcel Proust described habit as a “heavy curtain” that “conceals from us almost the whole universe,” and philosophy’s long history is a catalogue of schemes to draw back this curtain, deploying radical skepticism, thought experiments, or devious literary tactics to funnel attention in fresh ways.
Tara’s time loop proves a simple and ingenious method for dramatizing “that strange moment when the ground under one’s feet falls away and all at once it feels as though all predictability can be suspended,” and for interrogating the realization such crises yield: “that everything can change in an instant, that something which cannot happen and which we absolutely do not expect, is nonetheless a possibility.” This insight rehearses a well-known argument by the Scottish philosopher David Hume, who insisted that even our most reliable beliefs lack rational foundations. Our judgment that another day will dawn tomorrow can’t be proved; it’s just a habitual thought, formed piecemeal by accumulated experiences. Hume steadied himself by taking breaks from philosophy—a hearty dinner and a game of backgammon worked for him—but in Tara’s universe, there are no opportunities to slip back into unexamined life. Derailed from their well-worn tracks, her thoughts are swept in a cosmic direction; she marvels “that there are human beings on what we call our planet, that we can move around on a rotating sphere in a vast universe full of inconceivably large bodies comprised of elements so small that the mind simply cannot comprehend how small and how many there are.…That we exist at all.”
Tara’s account of her “before”—her final November 17—is peppered with the language of routine: “usually,” “often,” “as always,” “as a rule,” “mainly.” She speaks on our behalf when she observes that “we have grown accustomed” to the thought of our chancy origins, and instead of living “in constant amazement, we behave as if nothing has happened, take the strangeness of it all for granted.” By throwing both protagonist and reader into an altered existence in an otherwise familiar world, Balle tears down the curtain of habit to reveal the question of time, then amplifies this effect through Tara’s hyperattentiveness to detail. Time becomes both form and subject matter, both “container” and content.
in the first two books of Balle’s septology, Tara is alone in her time loop, cast into a bewildering new life that urgently brings to the fore the first of Kant’s famous questions: What can I know? Severed from the world, her “I” must rediscover itself. While the people she encounters on
正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。