返回资讯中心
外部精选
软件工程
#开发者实时流

Yonaguni Monument: Natural Formation or Man-Made Ruin?

Is Japan’s Yonaguni Monument a man-made ruin? Geologists say it is a natural sandstone formation, not a lost underwater city. Here is the evidence.

Hacker News 最新peter_d_sherman2026/10/17 · 2026/10/1730 分钟阅读

以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。

Is Japan’s Yonaguni Monument a man-made ruin? Geologists say it is a natural sandstone formation, not a lost underwater city. Here is the evidence.

In the winter of 1986, a diving instructor named Kihachiro Aratake dropped over the side of a boat off the southern tip of Yonaguni, the westernmost island in Japan, hunting for a reliable place to show tourists hammerhead sharks. Aratake, a director of the Yonaguni-Cho Tourism Association, knew these waters. Below Arakawabana cliff he found a wall of rock with flat faces, sharp corners, and a run of ledges that looked, to a swimmer suspended above them, like a staircase cut into the seabed. He surfaced with a story that would travel far past Okinawa.

Almost four decades later that story is still moving. In April 2024 the formation Aratake found became the flashpoint of a marathon podcast argument, and the phrase “Japan’s Atlantis” started trending again. The question people keep asking is simple. Did human hands build the Yonaguni Monument, or did the Earth?

No geologist who has published on the site apart from Kimura has argued that it is artificial. Every published assessment I can find reaches the same conclusion: the Yonaguni Monument is natural. What takes longer is why ordinary sandstone fools the eye so completely, why the man-made claim refuses to die, and what the sea itself records about when this rock last stood in open air.

The Yonaguni Monument (Japanese: 与那国島海底地形, Yonaguni-jima Kaitei Chikei, “Yonaguni Island Seafloor Topography”) is a submerged block of layered rock lying just off Arakawabana, the southern cape of Yonaguni Island. Yonaguni is the last scrap of Japan before Taiwan; about 108 kilometres separate the island from Taiwan at their closest points, close enough that Taiwan’s mountains are visible from Cape Irizaki on a clear day. The formation sits close to shore in shallow water, which is part of why it draws divers and part of why it became famous.

Reported dimensions vary from source to source, and that variation matters. Popular accounts describe the monument as roughly 100 meters long, about 60 meters wide, and around 25 meters high. Robert Schoch, a Yale-trained geologist who taught natural sciences at Boston University’s College of General Studies and who visited the site on two trips, in September 1997 and the summer of 1998, making several dives each time, described the main structure more conservatively as over 50 meters long east to west and over 20 meters wide north to south, with the top lying about 5 meters below the surface and the base at approximately 25 meters. Masaaki Kimura, the University of the Ryukyus marine geologist who champions the man-made view, gave larger figures still. His 2004 conference paper for Oceans ’04 MTS/IEEE Techno-Ocean, which is freely readable on his own site, puts the main monument at about 270 m long, 120 m wide and 26 m high, with the base at about 25 m, the upper terrace at 5 m and a metre of rock breaking the surface. The widely repeated figure of 290 meters does not appear in that paper; it is a downstream error that has been copied from blog to blog for two decades. The same paper puts the whole surveyed area at roughly one kilometre square with depths from 0 to 35 m, and it is not the same measurement as the 300 by 150 metres he gave National Geographic three years later, which covers the extent of the ruins he claims to identify rather than the area surveyed. Kimura told National Geographic that in total the ruins he identifies, ten structures off Yonaguni and five more off the main island of Okinawa, cover some 300 by 150 meters. No peer-reviewed metrology study of the underwater formation exists. These figures come from different instruments and different definitions of what is being measured, Schoch’s from hand-held reconnaissance dives, Kimura’s from SEABAT multibeam sonar, an underwater robot and SCUBA surveys, and they disagree with each other by a factor of five. Treat any single figure as approximate.

What everyone agrees on is the rock. The monument is carved from the local bedrock rather than assembled from separate blocks. The stone is sandstone and mudstone. The layers are almost horizontal. The block is cut by straight fractures. Those three facts explain nearly everything a diver sees.

Kihachiro Aratake is credited with the discovery in 1986. He was scouting dive sites for hammerhead viewing when he came across the terraced rock below Arakawabana cliff and recognized that it would draw visitors. Some sources give the date as 1987, and a few describe the discovery as a group of divers rather than a single person, so you will see both versions in circulation. Schoch’s 1999 acknowledgments settle the second question if not the first: he names Aratake as the man who discovered the monument, and as the guide for his own 1997 dives. The year itself stays a minor open point.

Word spread, though not immediately. Kimura, then a professor in the Department of Physics and Earth Sciences at the University of the Ryukyus, began his own study of the site in 1992, six years after Aratake surfaced with the story, though a team from his university had visited the formations not long after the discovery. In 1997 the Japanese businessman Yasuo Watanabe funded an informal expedition that put Schoch, the author Graham Hancock, the photographer Santha Faiia and the author John Anthony West in the water together, with Aratake himself as their dive guide. Schoch returned in the summer of 1998 with the Team Atlantis expedition and its documentary crew. That expedition matters, because it is where the two poles of the modern argument first met face to face over the same rock.

Almost everyone’s first reaction to the photographs is that someone built this. That reaction deserves a fair hearing before it gets taken apart.

Supporters of an artificial origin point to the concentration of unusual features in a small area: flat platforms, parallel faces, near right-angle corners, what look like steps rising from one terrace to another, straight channels resembling roads or drainage, two paired holes and a line of smaller holes that resemble the wedge sockets ancient quarrymen used to split stone, and a rock that from certain angles reads as a carved face. Kimura has argued over the years that he can identify a pyramid, castles, roads, monuments, and a stadium within the site. He has also pointed to markings he reads as resembling Kaida script, a set of pictographs once used in the Yaeyama Islands. Hancock, arguing the same corner, has stressed that while single features like these appear in natural sandstone worldwide, finding so many together in one place seems unlikely, and that the flat surfaces show a relative absence of the loose rubble you would expect from pure erosion and collapse.

The counter-case is geological, and it is the one that has carried the scientific community. The rock at Yonaguni is a sedimentary sandstone with strong internal structure: flat bedding planes stacked like the pages of a book, cut by two or more sets of steep, roughly perpendicular joints. Sandstone with that architecture, in a region shaken by frequent earthquakes, breaks into blocky, angular shapes on its own. Waves and strong tidal currents then scour away the loosened material along the fractures, leaving behind clean faces and flat treads. The result can look startlingly built, without anyone having built it. Crucially, the same step-like and terraced forms appear on the dry coast of Yonaguni Island and in the shallows nearby, where no lost civilization is invoked to explain them.

The man-made interpretation rests on pattern recognition and on the argument from improbability. It does offer physical evidence: quarry and wedge marks, characters said to be etched on carved faces, rocks read as animal figures, and the objects Kimura reports recovering, two chipped stone tools, an inscribed shale palette, a carved cobble. None of it has been published in a peer-reviewed archaeological venue or re-examined in print by independent specialists. And the one thing that would settle the question, cut blocks transported and set into place, has never been found by anyone.

The monument is built from the Lower Miocene Yaeyama Group, a sequence of medium to very fine sandstones and mudstones deposited roughly 20 million years ago. This is not a contested point; it comes from the geologist most often quoted on the natural-formation side, and it comes from rock samples, not from a distance.

Schoch collected samples during his dives and scraped away the coating of algae, coral, and sponge that makes the surfaces look smoother and more regular than they are. His description, published in 1999, remains the most-cited passage on the rock: the Yonaguni Monument “is composed predominantly of medium to very fine sandstones and mudstones of the Lower Miocene Yaeyama Group (the rocks themselves were deposited about 20 million years ago). These rocks contain numerous well-defined, parallel bedding planes along which the layers easily separate. The rocks of this group are also criss-crossed by numerous sets of parallel and vertical (relative to the horizontal bedding planes of the rocks) joints and fractures. Yonaguni lies in an earthquake-prone region; such earthquakes tend to fracture the rocks in a regular manner.”

Schoch is not a neutral outside referee here, and it is worth saying so plainly. He is best known for the Sphinx water-erosion hypothesis, an argument for a far older Great Sphinx that Egyptology rejects, and his popular books sit well outside the mainstream. He also reached Yonaguni in 1997 on a trip Graham Hancock helped arrange, and dived it with Hancock. None of that makes his rock description wrong: sandstone with parallel bedding planes and crossing joint sets is a routine field observation, and it is corroborated by everyone who has looked. But the argument here does not rest on Schoch, and should not be read as resting on him. It rests on the rock, on Ogata and colleagues’ onshore mapping, on Nunn, and on the sea-level curve.

Schoch’s essay, “An Enigmatic Ancient Underwater Structure off the Coast of Yonaguni Island, Japan,” is the original English draft of a piece that ran in Spanish in the popular-mystery magazine Más Allá de la Ciencia in May 1999. The English text has lived since then on the Circular Times site, and Schoch developed the same material in Voices of the Rocks, written with Robert Aquinas McNally and published by Harmony that year. It has never been peer reviewed, and yet it is the origin of the passage that thousands of blogs, videos and encyclopaedia entries have since repeated. So it deserves to be quoted accurately, but its status should be stated: this is a trained geologist’s field reconnaissance, self-published, not a study that passed through journal review.

The Yaeyama Group itself is well documented in the geological literature. Its sandstones crop out across Yonaguni and neighboring Iriomote Island, forming the low hills of the islands. Yonaguni sits at the far western end of the Ryukyu arc, along the subduction zone between the Eurasian and Philippine Sea plates, an active tectonic setting that keeps fracturing the rock.

A geologist looking at this outcrop sees three things stacked on top of each other, and once you can see them too, the steps stop being mysterious.

Sandstone deposited in flat layers inherits a set of horizontal weaknesses, the bedding planes, where one depositional event met the next. When such rock is later stressed, buried, uplifted, squeezed by plate motion and jolted by earthquakes, it also develops joints, which are fractures where the rock has pulled apart without much sliding. Joints often form in sets that are roughly parallel to each other, and different sets tend to meet at high angles. Combine one set of horizontal bedding planes with two sets of steep, near-vertical joints and you have, in effect, a natural

正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。

打开原文
去社区讨论 →