返回资讯中心
外部精选
软件工程
#开发者实时流

ADHD Is Not a Superpower

1 of them is a hypochondriac with 5+ other diagnoses.

Hacker News 最新paulpauper2026/11/10 · 7 天前30 分钟阅读

以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。

Sebastian Jensen

Oct 20, 2026

122

24

17

Share

10 patients with ADHD walk into a clinic

1 of them is a hypochondriac with 5+ other diagnoses.

1 of them is misdiagnosed, actually has severe sleep apnea.

1 of them is misdiagnosed, actually can’t get enough sleep.

1 of them is misdiagnosed — they are an immature or unintelligent teenager who will eventually grow out of most of their pathologies (hopefully).

1 of them is misdiagnosed, just needed a diagnosis to get access to adderall.

1 of them has ADHD, but is extremely unhealthy and has 3+ other comorbidities.

1 of them has ADHD, but is suffering more from undiagnosed depression.

Only 3 of them “have ADHD” — meaning they have similar symptoms, with different presentations and levels of severity.

You are a doctor working at said clinic. Let’s say you think that poor sleep and ADHD are linked. You take those 10 patients, find a reference group of psychiatric patients, and run the numbers. You find that 7/10 of the ADHD group have significant sleeping problems, compared to 33% of the others.

But there’s a problem here. 2 of the patients have a sleep disorder. The extremely unhealthy patient and the hypochondriac probably don’t claim to be sleeping pretty well. Only 3 of the remaining 6 are necessary for 7/10 of them to have significant sleeping problems. I suspect that a lot of statistics on ADHD work this way, where they are a function of both selection and the biological nature of the disorder.

From a definitional perspective, the DSM-51 says ADHD is a disorder that encompasses 3 different pathologies: inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity.

(ADHD is) a persistent pattern of inattention and/or hyperactivity-impulsivity that interferes with functioning or development. Inattention manifests behaviorally in ADHD as wandering off task, failing to follow through on instructions or finishing work or chores, having difficulty sustaining focus, and being disorganized and is not attributable to defiance or lack of comprehension. Hyperactivity refers to excessive motor activity (such as a child running about) when it is not appropriate, or excessive fidgeting, tapping, or talkativeness. In adults, hyperactivity may manifest as extreme restlessness or wearing others out with their activity. Impulsivity refers to hasty actions that occur in the moment without forethought, which may have potential for harm to the individual (e.g., darting into the street without looking). Impulsivity may reflect a desire for immediate rewards or an inability to delay gratification. Impulsive behaviors may manifest as social intrusiveness (e.g., interrupting others excessively) and/or as making important decisions without consideration of long-term consequences (e.g., taking a job without adequate information).

The book also specifies criteria used for diagnoses: that patients need multiple specific symptoms, that the symptoms should arise in separate environments (e.g. work, school, and home), and that there should be evidence of the disorder in childhood. There’s nothing special about these criteria, besides what they are meant for: identifying patients who need care accurately, quickly, and at ideal rates.

ADHD is an overwhelmingly genetic disorder; it has a high heritability: 70-80% in twin studies, when diagnoses are used as the measuring stick.

Like most psychiatric disorders, its liability follows roughly a bell curve distribution, and there is no concrete biological or genetic trait that defines it. ADHD is more accurately described as a label that matches to physical reality with some accuracy; what it really is or whether it exists are not the right questions.

from here

Attention deficit disorder is not desirable

ADHD is genetically correlated with the following traits: low IQ, depression, being overweight, poor health, and insomnia. Things people do not want to have.

from here

These might be just correlations, which can be biased by selection in terms of who gets diagnosis, but it’s still a bad starting point.

Another piece of evidence: when people take stimulants to treat ADHD, they improve in terms of functioning and life satisfaction. If ADHD was a superpower, you would expect treatments to make them worse. They don’t.

from here

Another piece of evidence: people with diagnosed ADHD tend to have more mutations. To date, every single rare variant associated with ADHD is a variant that increases risk2, suggesting that it’s been evolutionarily selected against. Evolution is trying to prevent it from manifesting, despite the fact that people with the disorder tend to have more children.

from here

Essentially, there’s a lot of evidence that suggests that ADHD is undesirable: it genetically correlates with a lot of negative things, mutations disproportionately cause it, and treatments intended to cure it make people feel and act better. So what’s the case for it being a positive?

When it comes to the benefits of ADHD, one thing disproportionately comes up: hyperfocus — the ability to spend a large amount of time and effort on one task.

Ignoring the futility of making a theory of what ADHD is, people with the disorder do not seem to struggle with the ability to focus in general.

The difficulties with focus tend to come when the task at hand:

Is not urgent, interesting, novel, or of appropriate difficulty

When people with ADHD do find a task they find rewarding or intrinsically motivating, they lock on to it. Perhaps if a software engineer had ADHD, and found coding to be intrinsically enjoyable, then they might end up being better at it than neurotypical people.

The next question then is: is that good? Maybe. Maybe not. Personally I find that intrinsic motivation can be quite powerful, but if it is not eventually rewarded from the outside, the motivation dries out. You get more depressed.

When one tries to accomplish a goal, some of the tasks will inevitably be tedious and painful. All careers have their version of office politics and peer review. Whether it is medicine, software engineering (code review?), film, or academia. .This also applies to great ambitions: a novelist must edit, a film director must practice his craft, and a philosopher must confront his physical limitations. People with ADHD are not good at doing things that are tedious or boring, and that makes them worse at accomplishing goals.

Beyond hyperfocus, some people think that mental illness causes genius: I’m generally opposed to the idea.

I can see the idea’s starting point. The world’s objects do not come with value judgements, so it’s possible that the kinds of nervous systems that are bad at being happy and stable are extremely good at doing stuff like making art. Maybe there is a gene that makes people better philosophers, but worse lovers.

Yet, the rule is that functionality correlates: richer people are generally smarter, more stable, and interpersonally skilled than people in the general population.

I’m also sympathetic to the idea that outliers are often idiosyncratic. I like looking into the biographies of artists I admire, whether they are novelists, film directors, manga artists, even entrepreneurs. I was reading about Kishimoto (author of Naruto) — he was a country kid who felt taken unseriously because of his background, which you can see in his writing; Isayama (author of Attack on Titan) — was physically underdeveloped student with bad grades who felt socially pressured, which you can also see in his writing; Stanley Kubrick — was a perfectionistic teenager who was obsessed with photography; and then we have people like Michel Houellebecq.

Art is an inherently unstable vocation, one that encourages the development of ideas that differ from others, where pay is irregular and success is not expected. Artists, even successful ones, are stereotyped as unstable or narcissistic. The kind of people who would commit to something that usually results in no material or social gain.

Then, you have the everyday model of artistic talent, which goes something like this:

Emotionally unstable people experience the world more intensely.

Intense experiences produce unconventional thoughts.

Unconventional thoughts produce original art, which is better than derivative art.

Consequently, psychological instability is conductive to artistic advancement.

On the other hand, being emotionally stable and disciplined as an artist could also be extremely helpful. The emotional stability allows one to endure periods of social or financial poverty; discipline tempers what ideas people put in their craft, and also allows them to create things more consistently and at higher rates.

The label “unstable person” is also incomplete. People who are internally stable might not necessarily be the same type of people who lead consistent, ordinary lives. In fact, it is probably the exact opposite: that people who are internally unstable need to balance themselves with external consistency.

Maybe, there are psychological qualities that cause people to have better artistic ideas (high neuroticism + openness), and then there are people with the psychological qualities to turn those ideas into implementations (high conscientiousness + neuroticism). I think both parts of the equation are equally important.

Besides the hyperfocus theorists, ADHD advocacy is common among people with antisocial attitudes and worldviews. Their idea is that people with the disorder who cannot focus are actually liberating themselves from the chains of society, that the impulses other people hate so much originate from good intentions or incentives.

The problem here is that people with the disorder seem to struggle in a wide range of areas: finances, happiness, fitness, you name it. Their ability to ignore what the man tells them to do also applies to… what they actually should be doing. If the median person with ADHD was a street-smart type who was hard to emotionally or socially manipulate, then you would not expect that to be the case.

I’m sympathetic to the idea that modern dating is not psychologically rewarding to many people, or that modern workplaces are too inhibited, structured, and devoid of meaning. Schopenhauer might have been a loser, but he was right about a few things. People with ADHD might not fit into those kinds of environments for reasons that go beyond their objective contributions.

The fact remains that attention deficit disorder is a disorder.

On a related note, I am not a fan of the theory that ADHD is a personality3.

In the big 5, we have extraversion, openness, neuroticism, conscientiousness, and agreeableness. ADHD diagnoses seem to relate to lower levels of conscientiousness, agreeableness, and higher neuroticism.

People with ADHD do exhibit lower levels of conscientious behaviour, but this has more to do with cognitive limitations than preferences or identitarian motivations (“I want/need to do X”). The water between what constitutes “personality” and “cognition” is already very muddy, but this is the way I see it: conscientiousness has more to do with a preference for correctness and deliberation, and less with how those preferences are executed in the moment.

Some people just don’t care that much about eating healthily, being productive, or keeping a clean house. Those people can simply be described as unconscientious or lazy. People who have attention deficit disorder seem to be suffering from a different problem: that they want to get things done, but can’t do them.

I also suspect that the average person’s mental weather is much more antisocial and dark than they let on. They just have the ability to control their impulses and ignore their strange thoughts. People with ADHD do that less effectively, so they look more disagreeable, but I don’t think that’s the same thing as being disagreeable.

Then we have the internet brainrot theory of ADHD, which is something along the lines of “not enough dopamine4”5. It’s wrong in the way one wou

正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。

打开原文
去社区讨论 →