
An Inauthentic TikTok and Instagram Network Inflaming the U.S.–Canada Trade War
All PublicationsIncident ReportNovember 12, 2026
以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。
All PublicationsIncident ReportNovember 12, 2026
Stolen Faces: An Inauthentic TikTok and Instagram Network Inflaming the U.S.–Canada Trade War
Aengus Bridgman, Esli Chan, David Hobson, Sequoia Kim, Mathieu Lavigne, Manon Paquet, Chris Ross, Ben Steel
On June 17, 2026, Ashley Hetherington, an American content creator, posted a four-minute TikTok about her thoughts on dating as a Christian woman. Months later, on October 25, 2026, a near identical video of Hetherington appeared again from an Instagram account called Raven, which Instagram labels as based in China. In the new video, Hetherington is seen talking about Canada’s job losses, U.S. tariffs, and Alberta’s referendum. Raven had taken the first 21 seconds of the original video and used AI tools to digitally alter her lips to match the new AI voiceover.
But Hetherington was not alone. By tracing the same format, titles, captions, and typos across Instagram and TikTok, we found a network of at least 293 accounts (36 on Instagram and 257 on TikTok) posting the same kind of videos. Between August 7, 2026 and November 4, 2026, the 293 accounts posted 3,201 videos with 22.1 million plays (82% on TikTok, and 18% on Instagram). During this time, posting activity of the network grew quickly, from three active accounts posting two videos a day to 157 accounts posting 108 videos a day. This period coincided with the Alberta referendum, the Quebec provincial election, the U.S. midterms, and an ongoing trade war between Canada and the United States.
This network joins a growing number of documented foreign inauthentic networks targeting Canadians: in April 2026, we found 20 YouTube channels selling secession narratives to Albertans, and in June 2026, we found a network of 340 Facebook pages monetizing AI-generated fake news. This new network stands out for its lack of any visible way to make money, its wide reach and considerable growth, its theft of creators’ likenesses, and the political focus of its activities. In this incident report, we investigate the network’s inauthentic activity, describe the content it is producing, assess its likely origins, and conclude with what this means for the Canadian information environment.
All counts in this report likely underestimate the network’s full reach, because it was still posting and expanding when we closed data collection.
Raven’s reel is typical of how the network makes many of its videos. Figure 1 plays Hetherington’s original video and then Raven’s inauthentic reel beside it, in step. Her head, hair, and eyes match the original frame for frame, but her mouth and lower face do not: they have been redrawn.
The same technique runs through the network. Between October 23 and 30, 2026, the inauthentic Instagram account @anasxpongofurrov43 posted six reels, all stolen from the same clip of creator Andrei Jikh, with six distinct scripts. Across all six, the head, eyes and shoulders move the same way, but the mouth moves differently (Figure 2). Across these videos, the message is inconsistent: The same Jikh is made to say that Canada’s economy is collapsing in one reel, and that Canada is building a future beyond the United States in another.
Almost every account (283 of 293) is built on footage of a single real person, stolen, where we could trace it, from that person’s own videos. We counted 226 distinct people and have been able to identify 104 of them. We also found three TikTok accounts that use fully AI-generated avatars.
The faces in the network overwhelmingly appear to be white women. Using FairFace, an open-source face-attribute classifier that estimates perceived gender and race (Kärkkäinen and Joo 2021), we found that of the 226 faces, 187 appear white. These 187 white faces account for 90% of the network’s plays. Another 23 appear to be East Asian, and the rest (16) appear Middle Eastern or Southeast Asian. None appear to be Black, South Asian, or Latino. Women outnumber men by five to one (188 to 38).
The network uses AI extensively for its deception. First, it pairs the stolen faces with synthetic voices generated by an AI text-to-speech tool. A deepfake-speech detector rates the narration as AI-generated in 94% of the network’s videos. Second, it uses an AI tool to generate realistic-looking lip movements that match the synthetic speech: the hair and eyes repeat exactly, but the mouth does not.
Third, many scripts appear to be written by AI. An AI-text detector (Pangram) rated an estimated 46% of the network’s scripts as entirely machine-written, including the network’s most-played story about an invented “48-hour ultimatum” from Trump. The scripts are also heavily recycled. Of 1,123 distinct scripts, 326 were posted more than once, and 142 were rewrites of an earlier script that say the same thing in different words. Scripts that do well get posted again. A reused script’s first video drew a median of 1,626 plays, against 664 for a script posted only once.
Building videos from real people’s footage likely helps the network avoid AI detection. TikTok’s AI label caught most videos with fully AI-generated faces (22 of 24) but almost none of those built on real creators’ footage (4%). None of the network’s videos disclosed AI use.
Almost everything the network posts concerns Canada, its economy, its government, and its relations with the United States. The biggest single topic is the U.S.–Canada trade war: tariffs, trade talks, and boycotts and their fallout make up 54% of its videos and 71% of views of network content. The most-watched scripted videos discuss Canada’s “one-sided” tariffs on U.S. goods, claims that the U.S. would save billions by cutting off trade relations with Canada, and an invented claim of a “48-hour ultimatum” from Trump. Trade war narratives dominate largely because the network reposts trade-related videos more often than anything other topic.
The network does not take a consistent side in the trade war. Of the videos focused on the trade war, attacks on Carney’s government are most common by number of videos (56%). However, almost every account takes both sides, and narrators switch nationality too, presenting themselves as Canadian in some videos and American in others. The effect is that Canadians are shown fabricated and misleading claims on both sides of the trade debate.
Most of the remaining videos cover Canadian domestic news, focusing on the economy, jobs, interest rates, housing, the dollar, and gold (23% of videos and 17% of plays). When this domestic content takes a side, it is almost always against Carney’s government (97% of the side-taking videos). 130 of 187 videos that spoke about the Alberta referendum promoted separation. The Epstein files and personal finance are also discussed.
The network consistently shows a disregard for the truth and many of its most watched videos contain fabrications. The most-played video claimed that Carney answered a “48-hour ultimatum” from Trump by cancelling $8 billion in U.S. defence contracts. This never happened, but the story was shared in 161 videos on 129 accounts and played 5.1 million times. Many other videos start from something real but have reckless distortions. For example, Canada’s talks with the European Union become a signed deal letting the EU decide whom Canada trades with. The youth unemployment rate becomes “Canada’s unemployment rate hit 13%.” The distortions cut both ways, against Trump and against Carney’s government.
A significant portion of the network’s audience are unknowing Canadian TikTok and Instagram users. We collected the follower and following lists of all 257 TikTok accounts, and found that the accounts have 42,538 followers, with 16,055 registered in Canada and 14,467 in the United States. Canadians find its videos through TikTok’s recommendations, and some then follow. The network follows many of them back.
Very few of the people who comment on the videos see the content for what they are: an inauthentic operation targeting Canadians and inflaming the U.S.–Canada trade war. Only 6.3% say or suggest that a video is fake, AI-generated, a bot, copied or propaganda. The rest agree or argue with the content in the video, and one in ten speaks to the narrator as a real person: thanking them, praising them, or telling them to check their facts. On TikTok, comments that talk to the narrator drew 3.5 times as many likes as comments that doubt the authenticity of the video (14,713 against 4,241), and none of the 100 most-liked comments doubt it (Figure 4).
Ultimately, we do not know why the network exists or who pays for it. However, evidence we have been able to collect indicates that the accounts are run from East or Southeast Asia, most likely in the UTC+8 or UTC+7 time zone. The only lead we have on a country points to China: some accounts carry Chinese-language settings or are registered there. That lead is limited, and it may reflect whoever supplied the accounts rather than the people who run them. We provide two kinds of evidence.
First, the network almost never posts between 1 p.m. and 7 p.m. EST (UTC−5), which is 2 a.m. to 8 a.m. in UTC+8, the time zone of China, the Philippines, and Malaysia (see Figure 5). Only 1% of its videos are posted during the Canadian afternoon and early evening. On TikTok, we could read the registration time of all 257 accounts. Of the 255 created in 2026, 80% were registered between midnight and 8 a.m. EST, with only 12 registered during EST office hours. The timing rules out North America and fits a working day in UTC+8 (China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, the Philippines, Malaysia, and Singapore) or, one hour behind, UTC+7 (Vietnam, Thailand, and western Indonesia). We checked app language settings and common typographical indicators to further narrow a likely geographic origin. While operators typically hide their country of origin and language in similar operations, we did find that twelve of the 184 we could check carry a Chinese-language app setting or are registered to China, against fewer than one in a hundred comparable accounts. This is the clearest country-specific lead we found. Many of the titles the operators type themselves show signs of non-native English, at several times the rate of other accounts posting on the same subjects. A few carry punctuation or phrasing typical of Chinese input software. Taken together, these traces suggest that Chinese speakers are involved somewhere in the operation, either among the people who run the accounts or the supplier who created them.
Second, the timing of the network’s posts does not fit a Canadian operator. For instance, Albertans voted in a referendum on October 19, but for 14 days afterwards, the network continued posting videos that describe the vote as still to come (43 videos on 37 accounts). Over the same days, other accounts in the network reported the result. Most of the 43 reused two scripts that had already run across the network before the vote, first posted on October 11 and 13. This suggests that the network draws on a shared pool of scripts and hands them out to its accounts without checking whether they are still current. Someone in Canada would be unlikely to miss the outcome of a major national story for two weeks.
Unlike the networks in our previous reports, which earned money from their content, these accounts show no sign of earnings. After nearly three months and 22.1 million plays, none of the TikTok accounts have reached 10,000 followers, the minimum threshold for TikTok’s creator payments. We found no links, products, sponsorships, or subscriptions in their posts. Most accounts are also based outside the countries that TikTok and Meta’s monetization programs currently support: TikTok lists 161 of the 184 accounts we could check as Canadian (Canada is currently shut out of per-view payments), and Instagram’s direct payments for reels are an invite-only test, offered in only some countries.
Nor do these accounts push any foreign government’s li
正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。