返回资讯中心
外部精选
软件工程
#开发者实时流

In open-weight AI, America is the one playing catch-up

China’s best open-weight AI model has outscored America’s every day since September 2024. Even America’s best new open models typically arrive three months after a Chinese one reached the same level.

Hacker News 最新kevin_hu2026/11/10 · 7 天前9 分钟阅读

以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。

China’s best open-weight AI model has outscored America’s every day since September 2024. Even America’s best new open models typically arrive three months after a Chinese one reached the same level.

China has led every day since September 2024

America’s best open models arrive months late

Both still trail closed models

How we built this

Open-weight AI models, whose weights anyone can download and run, have become China’s specialty. Labs like DeepSeek, Alibaba’s Qwen team, Zhipu and Moonshot release their strongest models openly, while most American labs keep theirs closed. Village’s LLM Atlas puts 857 models on one capability scale estimated from hundreds of public benchmarks, which lets us compare each country’s best open model day by day. By that measure, America’s open models have been behind for more than two years.

Alert me when a US open-weight model scores above the best Chinese one in the LLM Atlas.Which benchmarks show the largest gap between the best US and Chinese open-weight models?

The lead has held for more than two years. Meta’s Llama 3.1 405B last matched China’s best open model in September 2024, before Alibaba’s Qwen2.5 pulled ahead.

It is typically about five months of progress. Since 2025, China’s lead has usually been 6 to 8 points; Atlas’s frontier climbs about 1.4 points a month.

The latest push lasted two days. Meta’s Muse Spark Open cut the lead to 2.9 points on October 15; DeepSeek’s updated V4.1 Flash widened it two days later, and Moonshot’s Kimi K3.1 Pro took it to 7 points on October 24.

The pattern repeats: the gap narrows when Meta, OpenAI or Google ships an open model, then widens when DeepSeek, Zhipu or Moonshot answers.

Alert me when a new US open-weight model enters the LLM Atlas within two months of China’s best.

Every new American record since 2025 came after China got there first. The 12 record-setting US open models arrived a median of 3.3 months after a Chinese open model reached the same score.

Even the best showing was a month behind. Poolside’s Laguna S 2.1 came closest, at 1.1 months, in July.

More American labs are trying. Meta, Poolside and Thinking Machines have each released an open model within about three months of China’s best since July, after none did in the first half of the year. So far that has narrowed the gap without closing it.

Neither country’s open models have caught the best closed ones. Since 2024, China’s best open models have typically trailed them by about five months, and America’s by about nine.

This study uses Village’s LLM Atlas, which estimates one capability score per model from public benchmark results with a Bayesian item-response model, described in its methodology. For each day, we take the highest score among open-weight models each country’s labs had released by then, assigning labs to the country of their headquarters. Months behind measures how long before a model’s release a Chinese open-weight model first reached the same score. The scores are from October 31, 2026; Atlas updates as new results arrive.

Moonshot released Kimi K3.1 Pro on October 24 without weights. It is a post-trained version of Kimi K3, which Moonshot released openly, so we count it as open-weight on the assumption that its weights follow; counted as closed, China’s current lead would be 4.1 points instead of 7. Restricting to models scored on at least 10 benchmark families gives the same start date for China’s lead and similar gaps. Thirty scored models have no confirmed release date and are left out; none is an American model strong enough to have set its country’s frontier, so including them could only widen China’s lead.

We built this in Village. What will you build?

正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。

打开原文
去社区讨论 →