
In Praise of Ignorance
“It is not enough that you understand in what ignorance man and beast live; you must also have and acquire the will to ignorance. You need to grasp that without this kind of ignorance life itself would be impossible, th…
以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。
James Miller
Oct 10, 2026
57
23
19
Share
“It is not enough that you understand in what ignorance man and beast live; you must also have and acquire the will to ignorance. You need to grasp that without this kind of ignorance life itself would be impossible, that it is a condition under which alone the living thing can preserve itself and prosper: a great, firm dome of ignorance must encompass you.”
― Friedrich Nietzsche, The Will to Power #609
Last month, the cultural critic Naomi Kanakia, in her “Woman of Letters” Substack posted a long and impressively open-minded essay on the topic of “Little Magazines.” Proceeding methodically, as she always does, she chose a representative handful of little magazines, and then read, carefully and closely, the entire contents of each chosen issue. She then offered a variety of comments and observations, all cogently presented in clear prose that was effortlessly engaging, because written in a plain spoken style that had humor, intelligence and that indefinable fizziness of intellect that Pascal called l’esprit de finesse.
One of Kanakia’s arguments was that many little magazines seem to thrive on polemical essays, or editorials filled with spleen. She dissected a perfect example, a humorless diatribe recently offered by the editors of the magazine n + 1, warning against the threats to our species posed by AI: it augured, these editors proclaimed, the death of creativity, if not the extinction of the human spirit. Subtle the manifesto was not. Angry? You bet.
Kanakia’s piece, though measured in its tone, nevertheless provoked a pointed response from Simon During, a distinguished senior scholar and an expert on postcolonial theory and cultural studies. In a Substack article entitled “How Much Ignorance is OK?,” During scored Kanakia for exaggerating the influence on current little magazines of Partisan Review, and minimizing the importance of much earlier precursors, such as “the Jena romantics’ journal, The Athenäum (1798-1800) read by almost no-one at the time but which belatedly had a profound effect on the culture.”
Professor During also speculated that most of Kanakia’s many followers on Substack probably wouldn’t notice — because they were likely as ignorant as she was.
“Ignorance comes first,” During concluded, “in a contest where the question: how much ignorace is ok? cashes out, once again, into a question about what has happened to the academic humanities’ cultural authority.”
Gratuitously insulting the readers of Substack seems a foolish way to defend the bona fides of academic humanists. (And as anybody knows who has spent anytime in a University, having a PhD and being an expert in a scholarly discipline is no warrant of wisdom.)
Still, as Erasmus has taught us, folly is sometimes praiseworthy — and so it has proved in this case, as During’s reply to Kanakia has launched a fruitful debate on Substack about the strengths and limitation of little magazines, and the nature of cultural authority in the anglophone academy today.
Like Simon During, I am a professor — in my case, I’m an emeritus professor of politics and liberal studies at the New School for Social Research. For years I supervised dissertations written by graduate students, on topics from the political theories of Hannah Arendt and Leo Strauss to the legal philosophy of Roberto Mangabeira Unger. I’ve also published books of my own about Hegel, Marx, Sartre; Rousseau; Socrates, Plato, Augustine, Montaigne, Kant, Emerson, Nietzsche; the American New Left of the Sixties as a radical modern social movement; the history of rock’n’roll; the impassioned films of Pedro Almodovar; and the lived passions of Michel Foucault.
In part because I abhor the limits imposed by narrow specialization, I’ve also regularly written for magazines both little and large throughout my life. from Rolling Stone in the late 60s to the left theoretical journal Telos in the early 70s; from Newsweek throughout the 80s to Salmagundi, Raritan, Grand Street, and the London Review of Books subsequently. In much of my writing for magazines, I’m essentially a belle lettrist operating happily under what Nietzsche called “a firm dome of ignorance,” having written many articles, essays, and books on various topics without acquiring the proper credentials or deploying the cautious style that would imbue what I say with the “cultural authority” of a properly trained academic expert.
From 2000 to 2008 I edited Daedalus, the quarterly journal of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, in what was a challenging effort to help some of the most widely admired scholars in the world address in clear prose an audience of common readers, all of them unusually intelligent and widely read, but by no means expert in every field of academic inquiry. The prompt I sometimes gave contributors was to assume their readers were as smart as they were, but ignorant of the kinds of research they specialized in: explain as simply as you can what you and your fellow specialists are currently learning.
Obviously, a trained literary scholar like Professor During knows a lot about a lot of things, things that most people will know nothing about. During knows, for example, that the Schlegel brothers between 1798 and 1800 published the journal Athenaeum, which ran to three volumes and six issues and nevertheless found the readers its editors wanted to reach at Jena and nearby Weimar, thereby changing the contours of German letters.
Good for the Schlegel brothers, and good for both the German Enlightenment and Romanticism!
But the fact that such a little magazine briefly existed in Jena Germany, where Hegel would shortly afterwards write The Phenomenology of Spirit, is utterly irrelevant to the point that Naomi Kanakia made on Substack about the ongoing influence on American little magazines of Partisan Review.
In his pique at Kanakia, During willy nilly resorted to non sequiturs combined with an argumentum ad verecundiam, or appeal to authority. Perhaps his graduate training in literary scholarship had focused too much on rhetoric, too little on logic.
A decade ago, I convened a New School conference on little magazines, on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of Salmagundi, a venerable journal founded and edited by my old friend Robert Boyers, who was inspired in part by the example set by Partisan Review. Naturally, I invited a variety of veterans of Partisan Review to join the conversation — PR of course is THE inspiration for most little magazines in America today. This is where I first met Jon Baskin, one of the founding editors of The Point — I subsequently hired him to help me run a graduate MA program at the New School called “Creative Publishing and Critical Journalism,” which still exists and quite often attracts students who dream of starting a little magazine of their own.
Plenty of people at our event found the Partisan Review brand of rhetoric insufferable. After all, much of it was generated by Jewish intellectuals who had become polymaths in love with literature and philosophy and the passions stirred by political conflict. Trained as they were in dialectical combat, many of the PR veterans I got to know weren’t bashful about marshaling reasons for why a rival literary taste or political conviction was, in their view, simply a mistake.
Some of these men — they were almost always men — found their scholarly careers blocked in the academy of the day, anti-semitic as many universities still were at the time. Some of them became journalists before they found work as professors, and as a result some of them learned how to write a plain form of American prose, shorn of scholastic quibbles and pretensions.
I think of Daniel Bell, who I got to know at the end of his life.
Dan was a quintessentially American scholar, a widely read expert on sociology, but also an accomplished editor with an ear for demotic English, a writer who wanted to address an intelligent common reader. After World War II, he took a job working for Henry Luce. Subsequently, he revised the best of the pieces he wrote for Fortune magazine, and published these essays as The End of Ideology — a polemic that was also, at its best, a page turner, but a work of deep erudition, written by by a man with deep experience in the real world, as well as a broad knowledge of nineteenth and twentieth century social thought. Eventually, to Luce’s chagrin, Bell was offered a professorship, first at Columbia, then at Harvard. When I first met him face to face in 2000, in his office at the American Academy of Arts & Sciences, over his desk hung a framed copy of a Partisan Review cover — his first published piece of writing.
I also think of Mark Greif, one of the founders of n + 1, who was my colleague for awhile at the New School, and also of course of Jon Baskin. Mark could have become a great editor of a great small magazine, but he chose instead to become a professor; he now teaches at Stanford. Meanwhile Jon Baskin deliberately chose to devote himself to editing The Point (even though I thought he would make a brilliant teacher, and deserved a full time job that would be worthy of the variety of scholarly talents he had honed while getting a PhD from the Committee on Social Thought at the University of Chicago).
Substack has the potential as it evolves to become a kind of open forum where trained scholars can interact with ardent lovers of politics, literature and ideas.
In this context, I’d say, quite a lot of ignorance is not only OK — it’s a prerequisite for thinking new thoughts about hoary topics in the arts and sciences. A bit of whimsy goes a long way. Perhaps, as Emerson argued, it’s even a unique hallmark of The American Scholar.
Perhaps a rising generation of writers and intellectuals will leaven the crabbed caution of their learned teachers, and curb their instinct to parse every passing thought, in order to recommit themselves to a sheer love of the unknown, of reading widely and roaming freely, exploring the vastness of the universe, and the infinite riches of human experience.
In doing so, they would, like Naomi Kanakia and Jon Baskin, and Robert Boyers, rejuvenate a very great and very American tradition of letters.
正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。