
How to Stop Losing 17,500 Kidneys
If you're an organ donor in the U.S., there's a 25% chance your kidney ends up in the trash. Today's guests, Jennifer Erickson and Greg Segal, argue a government-enabled monopoly is the culprit.
以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。
Santi Ruiz
Apr 10, 2024
49
6
12
Share
If you're an organ donor in the U.S., there's a 25% chance your kidney ends up in the trash. Today's guests, Jennifer Erickson and Greg Segal, argue a government-enabled monopoly is the culprit.
We spoke with Erickson and Segal about how they successfully advocated for major fixes to the organ donation network. Erickson is a Senior Fellow with the Federation of American Scientists and former Assistant Director of Innovation for Growth in the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy. Segal is the founder and CEO of Organize, a nonprofit patient advocacy group.
Why are 28,000 organs going untransplanted annually?
Why does 1% of the federal budget go to dialysis?
Why has a sole bidder run the U.S. transplant system for decades?
[Thanks to Rita Sokolova for her judicious transcript edits.]
For a printable transcript of this piece, click here:
Jennifer Erickson: What I will say out of the gate about the organ waiting list is that it alternatingly makes me want to turn over the table, it makes me so angry because it's unnecessary. But then also the great thing is, this is actually a healthcare problem that we can fix. The problem, it turns out, is actually the federal contractors.
So who are the contractors? First, there are 55 local contractors. These are called organ procurement organizations or OPOs. Some have a state as their donation service area, some are across part of a state.
Congress set up a monopoly contract in the eighties, called the Organ Procurement Transplantation Network, or OPTN. This national contract has only ever been held by one contractor, the United Network for Organ Sharing. If you've seen Grey's Anatomy or ER and they said “I need a heart, get UNOS on the phone,” that's UNOS.
Just one example again of how bad it is: Greg and I recently got a whistleblower call in the last heat wave. Someone took a liver, a human liver that a family said yes to on the worst day of their life because a loved one died in an accident, and left it at the wrong hospital’s cargo bay in 90 degree heat, and no one noticed for an hour and a half.
The OPTN has a board to set policy. Who's on the board right now? The current board, the board members of the nation's Organ Procurement Transplantation Network, were until recently the exact same board members for the contractor, UNOS. So, literally, they would meet on a Sunday as OPTN board members and then on a Monday as UNOS board members.
To say it's a conflict is an understatement: it's a Venn diagram that just is one circle. It's really, really bad. So as a first thing, this legacy board is still deciding policy for the nation. There are ongoing, bipartisan Congressional investigations into conflicts of interest and corruption.
The tech is so bad. The United States Digital Service found 17 days of downtime in recent years. Until recently, the algorithm that was protecting all organ donor patient information in the country, so STI status, mental health, every physical history, was from 1996.
This is a fixable problem: it’s about the contractor, supply chain, it’s logistics, transparency. Congress unanimously passed a bill in July. The only other thing that passed unanimously that day was Tony Bennett Day.
Senator Todd Young, a Republican from Indiana, who lost a friend waiting for a heart, has done a lot of oversight into OPOs, including the OPO in Indiana. And in one year of that oversight — this has been peer reviewed and published — organ donation in the state of Indiana went up by 44 percent. It went up by 44 percent because they approached 57 percent more families. What in the hell was that government contractor doing before Todd Young started asking questions?
JE: The predecessor organization to UNOS lobbied heavily to insert language into the National Organ Transplant Act (NOTA) that stipulated that, to compete for this contract, a contractor has to be an independent nonprofit with expertise in organ donation and transplantation. That phrase has always been interpreted to mean UNOS. In 2018, the last time there was an open contracting cycle, you had to have three years of experience to even submit a bid to the federal government. Now, that might sound sensible until you realize that there’s a national monopoly and only one group has ever had three years of experience. So no one else applied.
The United States Digital Service produced a report called Lives are at Stake, which is not a normal name for a government report. It's a way of writing it in flashing red letters. They identified that phrase in NOTA as one that has restricted competition across decades, and in the summer of 2023, both the Senate and the House unanimously passed the Securing the U.S. Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network Act, which removed it. President Biden signed that into law in September.
It was surprising even to Greg and me how this news broke through in the national media, but I think it was because Americans inherently know that monopolies are bad and no one, unless you're in this very particular world of organ donation, was aware that there was a national organ monopoly and that they were funding as taxpayers, and which has spectacularly failed patients.
JE: I think one really important thing to know is that these organ donation contractors are funded by the taxpayer. Organ procurement is cost reimbursed, which means that pretty much anything organ procurement organizations pay for gets reimbursed by readers, by taxpayers.
From Organ Donation Reform
That’s how you end up with organ contractor executives flying around on private jets and going to Sonoma wine retreats while the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) say they're failing basic government performance metrics. If you're really worried about which vineyard you take your board to, you're probably not spending a ton of time thinking about how to staff underserved hospitals in the middle of the night.
I think the system has stayed broken for so long because they had budgets to market themselves. There’s a halo effect here: 95% of Americans support organ donation. That literally polls higher than puppies and ice cream. So there's this tremendous amount of goodwill that the organ contractors not only benefit from, but actively pay to perpetuate through good news stories, by sponsoring the Rose Bowl and professional sports teams. And despite wild executive perks and abuse of funds, these contractors are nominally nonprofits.
So no one was ever looking under the hood. And I really want to give credit to Greg here. When I was in the Obama administration in the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, Greg’s organization brought us data showing 28,000 organs going unrecovered every year, showing which organs were going unrecovered in which states. That put it into technicolor for us that we had not only a preventable, outrageous tragedy and a responsibility to actually fix it and prevent it. Greg and the researchers that he worked with showed that there are 17,500 kidneys, 7,500 livers, 1,500 hearts, and 1,500 lungs that go untransplanted every year from potential American organ donors. For scale, that means the United States does not need to have a waiting list for livers, hearts, or lungs within three years, and the kidney waiting list should come way down. That data convinced not only the Obama administration, but also the Trump administration. This reform movement has now crossed three administrations, and that almost never happens.
Greg Segal: So our organization, Organize, was awarded the Innovator in Residence position in the secretary's office of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) from 2015 to 2016. We were still technically a non-governmental nonprofit, but in some sense, we were embedded within HHS.
We had different levels of data access and we used ICD-9 codes, which have since been revised to ICD-10, to paint an objective picture of how well, or in many cases, how poorly, these industry stakeholders were performing. Many people probably directionally knew that something was amiss in this system, but it was very opaque. Before having this data, it was hard to articulate what was going on to members of Congress, and you sometimes felt like you were Christopher Lloyd from Back to the Future, where you're just the forensic accountant or crazy person in the office.
GS: We could access it as private citizens, but HHS employees really helped us understand why things were set up the way that they were, how things were coded, and which one of our ten ideas might actually be implementable. As Jennifer always says, government works by analogy. We had so many different ideas, and then civil servants would very soberly explain to us why nine of them were just completely unfeasible. When you're left with the one idea, that does not guarantee that it will happen. We then needed help understanding the ten different analogous projects that have happened in the last ten years to figure out how to implement ours.
So we used government data, and we validated it with some external data voluntarily shared from industry to verify that what we were doing was directionally correct with what was happening in industry.
JE: One of the things that really helped was the specificity. There had previously been federally funded research showing that in the United States as few as one in five organ donors were having their organs recovered. So four in five were not, right?
We knew that there was a gap between the huge support for organ donation and what was actually happening. What I’ve learned is that if there’s a big national problem, the government often does exactly the wrong thing. It punts, it does another big study, a consensus conference.
What you really need to understand is the data: what is happening in the state of Virginia, what's happening across Texas or California. There are 55 of these organ procurement organizations, and we found a 470% variability in recovery between the top performers and the lowest performers. You need to ask, “What are the top performers doing that the bottom performers are not?” That really helps you get specific and follow the data to find problems you can solve.
JE: So keep in mind, there's a huge generosity of spirit and national agreement about organ donation. Most people, myself included before I started this work, think of organ donation as, “Did you tick a box at the DMV when you got a driver's license?” And that really isn't the story of what happens.
In the United States, only 2-3% percent of deaths are organ donation-eligible. That includes car and motorcycle accidents, overdoses, strokes, and traumas: something that means a patient isn't going to make it, but up to eight of their organs might. When someone is dying in an organ donation-eligible way, that hospital calls the organ procurement organization they're assigned to. That OPO is supposed to turn up to every potential case in a timely and compassionate way and have one of two conversations with the family:
“Smith family, I'm so sorry for your loss. Jane was a registered organ donor. We'd like to proceed with her wishes.”
Or, “Smith family, I’m so sorry for your loss. Jane seemed like a wonderful person. Can we talk to you about organ donation?”
Keep in mind that 95% of Americans support organ donation. My older brother is a registered organ donor, and if, God forbid, something happened to him, and someone approached me at the hospital in a timely and compassionate way, I would consent to organ donation. If they do not approach me, then I cannot consent. If they do not show up at the hospital, even if he ticked the box at the DMV, those organs cannot be recovered.
Another problem is that when they do show up, OPOs are not requi
正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。