返回资讯中心
外部精选
软件工程
#开发者实时流

Plagiarism in the Age of AI

One can close one’s eyes and imagine how it feels to be standing in an open place, a prairie or a sea shore, while far away a big, reinless horse is approaching at a gallop, one can “see” it approaching and passing. To …

Hacker News 最新chmaynard2026/10/17 · 2026/10/1717 分钟阅读

以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。

One can close one’s eyes and imagine how it feels to be standing in an open place, a prairie or a sea shore, while far away a big, reinless horse is approaching at a gallop, one can “see” it approaching and passing. To do the same with a phalanx of a thousand of these big beasts is mentally impossible: your heart would miss a number of beats by pure panic, if you could!

Google indicates that I am the first person in the world to quote these passages. (For completeness, they are found on page 2.) If you can’t be bothered to provide the source for your quotation, you should not be quoting it at all.

Plagiarism is theft. So what does it mean to steal from yourself? It’s when you reuse your material inappropriately. Another of my hates from that 2015 round of refereeing was people who used the same text in their abstract, their introduction, and maybe even their conclusions. For one thing, the different parts of a paper have different purposes. You don’t use a toilet plunger as a cookie cutter. And once people notice you’re in the habit of reusing your own material, they are likely to give up altogether. I can remember a guy who gave me a bunch of his papers. I read one, then I picked up another, and another, and there were so many verbatim overlaps — whole paragraphs and worked examples — that I threw them all away.

Self-plagiarism takes another form, which I have been guilty of many times. It’s when you publish something in a conference, then submit it to a journal. The point is that a journal version will give you more views and more prestige, but you have to make it significantly longer and better than the conference version. These days you are expected to include a footnote to say that the journal version is based on your earlier work, which you should cite.

A typical paper starts with an introduction to motivate the work, followed by a section on background material. This should include the concepts and notation needed to understand the rest of the paper. Formal definitions, whether mathematical or otherwise, may be copied verbatim because they involve no originality. There really is only one way to define a prime number. On the other hand, explanations and examples still count as original.

In that bleak time in 2015, I faced again an old enemy: two incomprehensible pages of definitions involving low‑level syntax: terms and formulas, occurrences (positions) in a term, substitutions, unifiers, literals, clauses and on and on. I was never sure, but it seemed to me that they were exactly the same every time, as if a file of this crap were being shared to everyone who was worried about filling their page limit.2 Occasionally, I felt like checking how many of the definitions were actually used. The paper might still be good, but often I was tempted to grab my mouse and choose Strong Reject. Material of that sort belongs in an appendix.

Another source of boilerplate material is your acknowledgements. I remember seeing Prof. Gay accused of plagiarising her acknowledgements. And I am willing to bet a considerable sum that she did not acknowledge another person’s parents, professor or boyfriend. If you write “I am grateful to X for their unstinting love and support, to Professor Y for their wise and insightful advice, and to Z for not letting me give up”, you will score highly on the plagiarism detector. Fortunately, it doesn’t matter.

Since people have been drummed out of their jobs for plagiarism, it’s worth thinking about how it should be punished. For Cambridge students in straightforward cases, the rule is simple: the copied work receives zero credit. So the penalty hinges on how much was copied and how important it was, which is fair. Copying a few sentences for your introduction may cost you nothing beyond the ordeal of the disciplinary tribunal. No one cares about the acknowledgements at all. If, on the other hand, you have copied the heart of the work, you are likely to get a zero. And that could easily mean failing the course.

It’s remarkable how many media commentators seem to think that plagiarism is some sort of ultimate crime, especially for those of the wrong sex or colour. But it is not a crime in any legal sense: it is a form of academic misconduct and more common than many people realise. The appropriate response depends on what was copied and why. The same pundits who rage about alleged plagiarism seem to fall silent when other academics are implicated in actual and serious crimes.

Today, journals are overwhelmed by papers generated using AI. Some people say they should all be desk-rejected: AI sucks at writing, sometimes fabricates references and is an automated plagiarism machine to boot. It has been trained on existing texts and has been seen to output known texts verbatim.

We need to distinguish between papers generated using AI and those written with the assistance of AI. How can you benefit from AI as an author?

I find that AI is helpful at reminding me of things I should know but can’t easily recall. It might be good at suggesting things to cover in your introduction or conclusions. Perhaps, with the right prompt, you’ll get “the point of this work” (intro) as separate and distinct from “what has been learned from this work” (conclusions). And you can limit your abstract to five sentences.

AI can help analyse, manage, transform and present your experimental data. You still need to check that it did the job right. It is good at suggesting relevant references. You still have to locate them, check their details and actually read them, at least in part. (With a well-written paper, the abstract and conclusions should give you the essence.) One of my pet hates is too-long abstracts, introductions and conclusions, so do not allow AI to fill yours with drivel.

For non‑native speakers forced to write in English, the temptation to let AI do the job must be overwhelming. And yet your own English will likely more focused and coherent than anything that AI can write for you. If pressed for time, it may work to write in your native language and then ask a model to perform a literal translation. It will at least be your own voice.

Once you’ve got a first draft, a good language model is the best ever proofreader. I’ve been notified of everything from basic typos to LaTeX errors (the kind where LaTeX silently gives you the wrong output) to duplicate ORCID numbers and inconsistent punctuation. It can even notice mathematical errors and editorial bias.

Finally, AI is great when you get a pile of reports from not very happy referees. It will digest them for you, returning a well-organised summary of things you need to fix, why and for whom. Use AI for what it’s good at, not to plagiarise other people’s prose for you.

正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。

打开原文
去社区讨论 →