返回资讯中心
外部精选
软件工程
#开发者实时流

The origins of Stand-up comedy

I’ve written essays here—only somewhat tongue-in-cheek—about the meaning of “stand-up comedy” and the origins of stand-up.

Hacker News 最新andsoitis2026/10/17 · 2026/10/1713 分钟阅读

以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。

Kieran Setiya

Jun 01, 2024

12

2

3

Share

I’ve written essays here—only somewhat tongue-in-cheek—about the meaning of “stand-up comedy” and the origins of stand-up.

My topic today is entirely different: it’s the origins of “stand-up comedy.”

The question arose in the comments on my piece about stand-up as a theatrical form: why is “stand-up comedy” called that? The obvious root is that stand-ups stand up in front of an audience—in the early 20th century, they were “front-cloth” comedians, in front of the curtain at vaudeville or variety shows—delivering jokes or monologues directly, without song or dance.

[They] were called stand-ups not because they stood up, but because they worked in clubs associated with organized crime and in order to work there they had to be considered a "stand-up" type of guy. Surprising, right?

I had come across a version of this story once before, in Kliph Nesteroff’s book, The Comedians:

The Mob essentially created the term “stand-up comic”—according to eighty-six-year-old comedian Dick Curtis. “The Outfit used to manage fighters. A stand-up fighter is a guy that is a puncher. A stand-up guy was a guy who was tough and you could depend on. The Outfit managed fighters and they managed clubs that booked comics, so the term found its way into the lexicon of nightclubs. A guy who just stood there and punched jokes—joke, joke, joke—he was a stand-up comic.”

The tale has several twists. In 2017, Oliver Double, noted scholar of stand-up comedy, wrote an essay on the origins of “stand-up” that took aim at the OED:

The Oxford English Dictionary is still citing the earliest usage of ‘stand-up comic (also comedian)’ from an article published in The Listener on 11 August 1966. … If 11 August 1966 really was the first use, that would put it eight days after the death of Lenny Bruce, meaning that this icon of stand-up comedy would never have used the term himself. I quickly discovered an earlier use in Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, published in 1961, which gives a definition of the adjective ‘stand-up’ as: ‘[P]erformed in or requiring a standing erect position <stand-up lunch> <stand-up bar> <stand-up comedy act> <stand-up boxing stance>’.

Intriguing, this: an earlier citation from America; and the hint of a connection with boxing. No mention of the Mob, but consistent with the origin story above—as are the precedents Double finds.

The earliest term seems to be stand-up comic—in a review of a show at Slapsy Maxie’s in Los Angeles, dating from 23 June 1948: ‘When not at his trade of stand-up comic, [Lou] Holtz is ringmaster of the floor show’ (Variety 1948). Stand-up comedian is slightly younger, not occurring until 12 April 1950: ‘Male talent getting the Columbia buildup include Steve Allen, a so-called “standup” comedian who has been groomed for the big time on the Pacific Coast Network’ (Variety 1950).

There are older uses of “stand-up” in connection with comedy, going as far back a as 1911, but they refer to singers of “comic ditties” like Miss Nellie Perrier. As Double concludes:

[The] term stand-up being used to define a style of comic performance seems to be of American origin. After its first occurrence in 1948, it was common in the American trade press throughout the 1950s. By contrast, it did not appear in the British trade press until the following decade.

In the UK, stand-ups were “front cloth comics” up until the 1960s.

But here’s the twist. Double’s essay ends with an exhortation:

You may consider this short article a challenge. I will be delighted if others manage to find earlier usages.

Within a year, he had published an “update,” based on a discovery by Duncan Law.

In the ‘Stage Gossip’ column of the Yorkshire Evening Post, dated 10 November 1917, there is an item about a performer called Finlay Dunn, who was presenting an act made up of comic songs at the piano at the Leeds Hippodrome that week. … Crucially, the article states that Dunn ‘made his way, in former times, otherwise than as a rattler of “the dominoes.”’ In other words, he did not appear in concert parties as a pianist. Instead, ‘He played, in those days, simply as what he calls “a stand-up comedian,” though he must have been a useful deputy for the piano’.

This looks like an allusion to “stand-up comedy” all the way back in 1917—a British source for “stand-up,” unrelated to the Mob.

But there’s a final twist, or catch: it’s not clear, on reflection, what the reference implies. Does the fact that Dunn was not a pianist mean he was a spoken-word comedian—a “stand-up” in the modern sense—or that he didn’t sit on a piano bench, but stood at a microphone, to sing comic songs?

And so we find ourselves back at, or close, to square one. There is equivocal evidence that “stand-up” meant stand-up circa 1917, in Leeds, but nothing definitive before L.A. in 1948.

To echo Double: You may consider this essay a challenge. If you have evidence of the early origins of “stand-up comedy,” let me know!

正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。

打开原文
去社区讨论 →