返回资讯中心
外部精选
软件工程
#开发者实时流

I used celestial vision navigation to solve a mystery place in Elite:Dangerous

Maybe the real treasure was the friends we made along the way.

Hacker News 最新XenonofArcticus2026/10/20 · 26 天前30 分钟阅读

以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。

Maybe the real treasure was the friends we made along the way.

In 2012 I was one of the original Kickstarter backers (November 2012 – January 2013) of the (then) new Elite: Dangerous, released in December 2014: an ambitious new sandbox space game to succeed David Braben and Ian Bell’s pioneering 1984 8-bit game (and its 16-/32-bit era sequels, Frontier: Elite II in 1993 and Frontier: First Encounters in 1995). I played the original on the Commodore 64 (crashed many times during the difficult 3D docking sequence) and never became more skilled than the second tier, “Mostly Harmless”. The copy protection on that C64 game was a nasty Lenslok lens device that you held up to the TV screen. It was supposed to work on any size of TV, and it was very finicky.

Anyway, Elite Dangerous brought us a galaxy-sized play space, with uncounted REAL star systems, planets, exploration, combat, mining, piracy and trade. In the years I’ve owned it since the first betas, I’ve visited over 5700 star systems, traveled 258018 light years, and made 7267 hyperspace jumps, ending up a maximum distance of over 65000 light years from the starting point. At one point I traveled to the edge of the galaxy with Distant Worlds 2, and we had our own Squadron ( https://www.canislupusmajoris.com/ ). I have even traveled to the top of the disk, until I couldn’t go any further.

From late 2015, the game’s main menu showed an enigmatic dark space station, spinning in front of a planet, with an SRV (ground vehicle) exploring a moon in the foreground. The station was of particular interest, since in the game’s lore, a “Dark Wheel” location (interpreted as being a stealthy, or dark, wheel-shaped space station) is a central tenet in some of the unsolved mysteries. The primary mystery is a place called Raxxla, which is sort of the Shangri-La of the game’s lore. Said to exist, but nobody knows how to get there. The game’s designers are said to have claimed, in a LaveCon Q&A session (2017-ish) that was never recorded as far as I know, that it does exist, is in-game, and that the star system it is in HAS been visited by a player as of the time of the Q&A. (The only account is CMDR Ascorbius’s recollection on stream in 2020; author Drew Wagar never managed to pin it down either.)

Around 2019, I started having thoughts of hunting for this station’s location with computer science, computer vision, vision navigation and celestial navigation, built on top of deep machine learning.

The problem space is large. There are an estimated 400 BILLION (Dr Evil pinky gesture) actual or procedurally placed star systems in the ED Milky Way galaxy. The galaxy isn’t stored anywhere in full. Frontier’s procedural generator, the Stellar Forge, builds each system on your own computer, the same way every time, from the system’s location and ID, so every player sees the same thing (Frontier’s Doc Ross on 80.lv, 2018). Frontier’s servers only track the shared, changing parts: stations, factions, who discovered what. Third-party mapping tools like the late EDDB (shut down in April 2023), and now EDSM and Spansh, collect user-contributed data from your game’s journal files to build community maps. EDSM alone held about 95 million systems and 457 million bodies in March 2026 (archived EDSM home page), and EDAstro counts about 205 million systems known to players as of October 2026. That’s roughly 0.05% of the galaxy, charted by the owners of about 6 million copies of the game (Frontier annual report 2026).

So in my devious little mind, there were two visual cues I could use to try to solve this mystery, and maybe be the first to find an answer and unmask Raxxla.

The first is the appearance of the Milky Way disk in the picture. ED renders the panoramic backdrop of the greater galaxy each time your ship jumps into a new star system (“we render a skybox (not containing stars) during hyperspace… The stars are rendered as little billboards”, Frontier’s Ben Parry, 2014). Due to the sizes of things, the parallax doesn’t change enough between the star and the outermost planet, so a simple 2D panorama is enough. The appearance of the Milky Way from your position is therefore genuinely real. If you go way above the galactic plane, you start to see it spread out below you. In the middle, you see it all around you. Out on the edge at Beagle Point, it is only off to one side, with the black of the deep intergalactic void in all other directions (I’ve been there, it’s creepy). And the disk isn’t symmetric: clouds and whirls look different from Beagle Point, Sol, and other arms of the spiral.

The second, once we have SOME idea of where we might be, and if it’s near Sol (Earth’s system), is to actually plate-solve the stars (Lang et al. 2010). Identify what they might be based on their brightness and color and the positions and angles of each relative to the others. It isn’t practical to do this with hundreds of billions of stars, but if you can pin down the local neighborhood of the galaxy, it might be feasible to dial in the accuracy with plate solving to pick out a system or group of systems that are most likely, which could then be explored in person.

Spoiler: I did both of these things, and I now know where the animated splash screen showing the dark wheel-type station was captured. But you’ll have to jump to the end for the juicy goods. First I’ll explain the process and math.

In the 1984 Elite game, the included novella The Dark Wheel by Robert Holdstock mentions Raxxla as a mythical world with an alien gateway, and “The Dark Wheel” is a brotherhood of legend-seekers. I don’t recall Raxxla being mentioned in Frontier: Elite II (1993), because I only played that briefly, not having the time and focus to dedicate to the game at that time in my life. Elite Dangerous mentions it again, and the in-game Codex entry for the Dark Wheel relays a conspiracy theorist’s claim that the original group “was based in a disused starport orbiting the eighth moon of an unnamed gas giant. The station was toroid, hence ‘wheel’, and operated with a minimal power output so as to avoid detection, hence ‘dark’.”

The Elite Dangerous Horizons main menu (December 2015 – April 2019) looped a video (FrontEnd1.webm found at https://www.reddit.com/r/EliteDangerous/comments/b89fbm/ ) which showed an SRV parked on a dark moon, a large planet, and the Milky Way. It had a slowly rotating Orbis-class station with no lights. So, it sure felt like someone shoving “the Dark Wheel” in our faces, and it got my attention. In April 2019, I (u/XenonOfArcticus on Reddit), representing our squadron Canis Lupus Majoris, proposed a community project to localise the menu starfield from explorer screenshots: Repost with permission: Collaborating on an E:D Deep Learning pet project searching for the Dark Wheel/Raxxla? (r/EliteDangerous, 16 April 2019). I was partly inspired by a 1 April 2019 thread by u/KoalaKvothe. Frontier replaced the scene in the April 2019 update (the menu now shows your own ship), and never commented on the station, as far as I can find. My 2019 plan used learned image matching (SIFT/SURF, CNNs) on screenshots of the galactic cloud.

The same problem appears in our client work wheelhouse wearing other masks: attitude determination (star trackers, “lost-in-space” solvers), camera resectioning / Perspective-n-Point (PnP) (AR registration, photogrammetry, robotics), navigation without GNSS (vision-based localisation; see our vision navigation overview and toy vision navigation system), image forensics (was this image flipped, cropped, composited, otherwise altered?), and signal processing (frame stacking, noise reduction, image metrics). The Elite Dangerous video game is a perfect laboratory. Its renderer is deterministic, its star catalogue is public (ED uses actual astronomical data and star catalogs, augmented by procedural fillers), and players have published thousands of ground-truth screenshots with known locations. There’s a real-world practical example: in April 2020 NASA’s New Horizons imaged Proxima Centauri and Wolf 359 from about 47 AU and demonstrated interstellar parallax navigation (NASA release, June 2020; the full analysis is Lauer et al. 2025, AJ 170, 22, which fixed the spacecraft’s position to 0.44 AU from the star images alone). So this is our bread-and-butter skillset, my daily bread with a shot of Leestian Evil Juice (a potent in-game liquor, and more game lore).

The primary source is ED’s own webm asset, extracted from disk (1920×1080 VP8, 30 fps, 2,699 frames, ~90 s loop; Fig. 1). I started my 3D career doing desktop video and 3D animation, so I’ll comment on this in a film vernacular hybridized with a forensic image analysis dash of spice. The camera is locked off. Only the station rotates (and the SRV lights flicker), so every star pixel is a time series of one value plus codec noise. The station stays mostly in one place except for the arms (and wheel) spinning, so some part of the scene is blocked by it unrecoverably. Obviously the unmoving planet and moon block some of the scene, and the sun and glare obscure some. Frame stacking with median selection can recover the most common pixel value in locations where the station arms SOMETIMES hide the night sky, and improve the SNR and decrease compression artifacting in spots that don’t intentionally change (Fig. 2). This is just like stacking multiple astrophotography frames from a telescope to remove satellites and other brief artifacts and improve the capture of the unmoving stars you want. Here’s a frame-stacking example of my own from Kenya, looking at the night sky over Kilimanjaro (Fig. 3). It’s a phone shot: the Pixel’s Night Sight astrophotography mode takes up to 15 frames of up to 16 seconds each, then aligns and averages them (Google Research, 2019).

Since the camera doesn’t actually move with respect to the starfield, we can’t exploit super-resolution methods to get sub-pixel data the way you can with untracked or imperfectly tracked astrophotography. The renderer is too perfect to leak any extra detail. We can, however, centroid each star’s point spread function (PSF) to get a sub-pixel star-center location. The renderer draws each star as a small antialiased blob, so this is fabulous for us. VP8 only stores colour at half resolution (4:2:0), so colour is the least reliable star feature, but the geometry is more important anyway.

My original plan was to enlist an army of adventurers to travel the galaxy submitting screenshots of what the galactic cloud looked like, then train a deep learning model on those, with the actual galactic coordinates and possibly camera pose (where is the center of the galaxy, Sagittarius A*, in the image) as output, and then use a second set of test data excluded from the training to see if I could localize arbitrary unknown galactic-disk images. But I was lazy and in a hurry and didn’t want to assemble a new army in 2026, so I did some searches and amassed 40 online screenshots ranging from the core and Colonia to the rim and far off the plane. Auto-exposure and changes in the renderer over time confused this a lot. The whole deep-sky renderer has changed at least a couple of times, and older shots have different amounts of yellow than newer ones. But, subjectively, the closest matches were views toward the core from the inner disk, at the Eagle and Trifid nebulae, about 5,000 to 7,000 ly from Sol. They show a cream band with an amber dust lane just like our candidate. This was kind of exciting, because there totally could be an overlooked system out there.

I tried some real CSI stuff on the cross-band profile, trying to pin something down. There just wasn’t enough to work with in the screengrab, though. And, after looking, I realized that the neighborhood of Sol itself also looked fairly similar. What I COULD tell was where it WASN’T. It wasn’t way out on the rim, or very far off the plane of the galactic disk. So, that’s gotta be worth something. It’s pos

正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。

打开原文
去社区讨论 →