
Ways to Handle a Throwaway Account
I think that with the prevalence of online accounts people are forced to interact with, many of which are low priority for the user for much of the time, we’re going to see more and more throwaway accounts. These accoun…
以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。
Dan Moore
Nov 16, 2026
∙ Paid
Share
Heya,
I think that with the prevalence of online accounts people are forced to interact with, many of which are low priority for the user for much of the time, we’re going to see more and more throwaway accounts. These accounts are not useless. They might be accessed infrequently. The user might be exploring the functionality and uncommitted. The app might be really important to the user right now, but not in the future.
The accounts I’m talking about are things like:
Regardless of the user’s opinion, having an account is important to the company, otherwise they would not add that friction. Often, knowing who the user is matters for delivering the service.
How do you know if you have an application with accounts of this type? It can be humbling to say “my app is low priority to users”, but flip it around. Think of your app as “not high-priority at all times”. If an app serves a need for 30 minutes a year, that doesn’t mean it is unimportant. It just means it isn’t very important for most of the year. For that 30 minutes, it might be very important!
So, look at your users’ patterns. Do they come back often? Do they engage with your application? Do they reset their password every time they visit? Be clear-eyed about the engagement patterns and understand what type of application you are offering. Collect metrics like:
Start with options below, measure usage, then invest in what people actually use, making it easier and easier.
Let’s talk about different ways to handle these types of accounts. (This post was spurred by my conversation with Mike Hadlow.) First I’ll look at how users can handle these accounts, then what that means for you as a builder.
Let’s rule one all-too-common option out right away: using the same password for all of your throwaway accounts. This is a bad idea because you don’t know if any of these systems will be compromised. If any are, the attacker may try to crack your password and credential stuff against other accounts. Please don’t do this.
As a user, the first real option is to use a password manager to create an account and keep track of the password. You don’t really care about the password value. This approach is generally safe because password managers are usually robust and secure. It’s easy because you don’t need to remember the password. If you need to share the password with someone else, you can do so. If you are on a different device without access to the manager, you simply use the account recovery process.
However, you are trusting the password manager to secure your passwords. While they are typically secure, there have been breaches. Depending on your chosen solution, there may be a cost as well.
Another option for temporary, throwaway credentials is the forgot password flow, or the account recovery flow. In this option, you skip the password manager and use a random string (I like random.org). Almost every identity system has account recovery, especially for these types of accounts.
Typically, you keep pretty good track of your email access. It’s far easier to say, “I’m just going to set my password to some super random value that I don’t remember, and the next time I need access to this app, whether it’s in a month, a year, or two years, I’ll just tap ‘forgot password’” than it is to use a password manager.
Instead of going through account recovery every time you log in, you can simplify things and use a one-time password (OTP), whether that is a code or a magic link. This is simpler because you’re not resetting a password. Instead the ownership of some message receptacle, typically email or text messages, is proof of your identity.
There are sometimes deliverability issues, and if you lose access to that inbox, you’ve lost access to the application. But you tend to pay close attention to your email or messages app, and you’re more likely to secure them using MFA than some random website account.
正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。