返回资讯中心
外部精选
软件工程
#开发者实时流

Forget 'defund the police'. the US needs more cops

Malcolm Gladwell’s new book tackles America’s gun violence epidemic, but his quick-fix solutions leave big questions unanswered

Hacker News 最新lifeisstillgood2026/10/17 · 2026/10/1724 分钟阅读

以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。

Malcolm Gladwell’s new book tackles America’s gun violence epidemic, but his quick-fix solutions leave big questions unanswered

Jessa Crispin is a writer and cultural critic covering literature and film. She is the author of What Is Wrong with Men, The Dead Ladies Project, among other books, and the editor of The Culture We Deserve.

Add us as preferred source

America loses around 45,000 people every year to gun violence

Credit: AFP/Charly Triballeau

Jessa Crispin

Show biography

Jessa Crispin is a writer and cultural critic covering literature and film. She is the author of What Is Wrong with Men, The Dead Ladies Project, among other books, and the editor of The Culture We Deserve.

To an outsider, America’s problem with guns may look absurd. Every so often, a teenage boy will take an assault rifle to a school or a local shop and mow people down indiscriminately, before either killing himself or being mowed down by heavily armed police. Politicians will gather and suggest that something needs to be done. Generally, nothing is done. When the next shooting comes – a few months, weeks or days later – the entire cycle repeats.

But though mass shootings are depressingly regular, they’re also, as Malcolm Gladwell correctly notes, responsible for a mere fraction of the gun deaths in America. They are heavily outweighed by individual murders, suicides and accidental shootings (of the very American “Toddler shoots baby” and “Dog shoots man” kind). Put all the above together, and you find that America loses around 45,000 people every year to gun violence. It’s a tremendous waste of life, resources and potential, and yet we’ve simply become used to it.

As Gladwell remarks in his new book, The American Way of Killing: “This does not happen anywhere else in the developed world.” Indeed, there’s no reason for it to happen anywhere.

The reason why it happens in the Land of the Free, according to Gladwell, is that the conversation around guns has become fatally tangled in falsehoods and misunderstandings. “A conversation becomes dishonest,” he writes, “when either side pretends something is consequential when it is not, avoids the right conclusion just because it is difficult, or through laziness or indifference blinds itself to the truth.” (In fact, he writes this a couple of times, with slight variations, and even puts it in italics to ram it home.)

Gladwell points out some places where the debate frequently gets stuck. The US Supreme Court, for instance, has struck down attempts at gun control by pointing out that ownership is protected by the Second Amendment to the Constitution. But with a flourish, he reinterprets the meaning of the Amendment as pertaining to the protection of early American plantations against slave rebellions. His exegesis is fairly convincing, though I wondered whether it mattered. It probably won’t be effective in litigation, nor in ending the court’s blockade.

Gladwell points out, in similar temper, that the call to ban assault rifles – the one proposal for reform that has widespread popular support – won’t have a significant effect on gun violence. The legislation is not comprehensive, and assault rifles account for a very small percentage of murders. When Americans propose gun control, they’re often thinking about planned violence – mass shootings, or “first-degree” murder. But the vast majority of violence is, Gladwell writes, “expressive”.

Everyone in the world gets into arguments with neighbours, loved ones, work colleagues and other commuters. The difference is that when an American argues, there’s a good chance they have a gun to hand. Preventing this violence requires better education and more police officers on patrol. (Gladwell doesn’t consider that a ban on assault rifles could mark a cultural shift, which might have an effect beyond saving a handful of lives a year. Besides, aren’t those lives worth trying to save?)

Malcolm Gladwell’s characteristically counterintuitive arguments leave plenty of questions unanswered

Credit: Shannon Greer

As for the “defund the police” debate, Gladwell points out that European cities such as Berlin and Brussels have roughly twice as many police officers per capita as comparable American cities. You often hear that America is over-policed – an idea supported by the enormous bite that police departments take out of municipal budgets – but the reality might be that there are too few officers, versus too much surveillance tech, militarised hardware (such as armoured vehicles) and outsourced lab work, all of which bloat budgets without providing enough in return.

At this point, it’s worth pausing. It’s difficult to read a Malcolm Gladwell book without anticipating the long list of corrections that will soon follow. In his 2024 book, Revenge of the Tipping Point, Gladwell revisited some of the ideas in his bestselling 2000 debut, The Tipping Point, about how trends begin. For example, police tactics such as stop-and-search and the “broken-windows theory” didn’t actually do much to bring crime down. (Still, it was savvy of him to sell a book that revisited how his previous book was wrong, and still leave the original on the market to boot.) Then there was Outliers (2008), and its notorious “10,000-hour rule”, which suggested, in a nutshell, that elite status in anything required around 10,000 hours of practice. That doesn’t hold up either, as researchers and critics have pointed out.

Reality, then, has generally proved more complicated than Gladwell has liked to suggest. That pattern may have inspired him to change tack. Roughly a quarter of The American Way of Killing comprises excerpts from the transcripts of Revisionist History, a podcast he’s been hosting since 2016. In 2023, he ran a six-episode mini-series on gun violence, and in this new book’s acknowledgements, he credits five individuals with helping to turn that podcast series into a book. Perhaps spreading the work will help with the fact-checking. For my part, I’m unsure that the difference between German and American crime rates can primarily be explained by police numbers. These are two vastly different contexts. The issue seems far more complex than that.

Mourners attend a vigil for the 17 victims of the high school shooting in Parkland, Florida

Credit: AFP/Rhona Wise

Gladwell himself is an outsider, and views this topic with horror. He wants to know why, in his birth nation of Canada, “a young boy like me can grow up without any first-hand experience of lethal violence at all, and in [the US], a young man can bury more than a dozen of his close friends by his 30th birthday”. This is a good question. It’s frustrating, then, that he prefers the alluring explanation to the proper, sustained, exhaustive argument. Does he investigate why American police forces are so oddly small? Or why they spend those budgets on vehicles instead of recruits? Or the role played by police unions in blocking reform? No. He prefers to point out something attractive and plausible, weave a spell around it and wait for someone else to figure out the details.

Hence, when looking for an example of an American city that has dealt effectively and comprehensively with its gun-violence problem, he writes about 19th-century Dodge City, Kansas, instead of the contemporary example of Baltimore, Maryland, where homicides have fallen to historic lows and violent crime as a whole has dropped precipitously. Since he won’t tell you, I will. Baltimore’s approach to reducing violence, spearheaded by Brandon Scott, the mayor, has been tediously holistic, involving dogged collaboration between the likes of health and housing departments. That is much harder to document and analyse, and much less fun, than simply attending a Wild West-themed performance at a Kansas tourist trap.

But Gladwell loves his fun. In his world, an attorney who frequently argues before the Supreme Court is “the LeBron James of litigators”, and the early-20th-century murder of a famous writer is “the OJ Simpson case of its era”. These analogies don’t hold up to the slightest scrutiny, but before you know it, he has moved on.

Just as it’s impossible to read Gladwell without worrying about future corrections, it’s also impossible to read Gladwell without wondering which bits of information you’re going to hear at parties, further decontextualised and half-remembered. The bits people will pick up from The American Way of Killing will probably be the counterintuitive gotchas – “an assault-rifle ban won’t accomplish anything”, or “the real problem is that we need more police”.

It doesn’t matter, in the end, whether these are true or not. As with a politician offering “thoughts and prayers” instead of legislative reform, nothing will change.

The American Way of Killing is published by Abacus at £25. To order your copy for £19.99, call 0330 173 0523 or visit Telegraph Books.

The Telegraph values your comments but kindly requests all posts are on topic, constructive and respectful. Please review our

commenting policy.

Copy link

正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。

打开原文
去社区讨论 →