返回资讯中心
外部精选
软件工程
#开发者实时流

Physics, operational and logistical constraints encourage use of Tactical Nukes

How physics, operational, and logistical constraints may encourage the usage of MRR Tactical Nukes

Hacker News 最新CGMthrowaway2026/10/17 · 2026/10/1730 分钟阅读

以下正文同步自 Hacker News 最新,版权归原站所有,已转换为易读排版。

Geopolitics

Nuclear Weapons

Military

Politics

How physics, operational, and logistical constraints may encourage the usage of MRR Tactical Nukes

Joseph

8 min read·

Feb 24, 2026

--

The first nuclear bombs ever used, Fat Man and Little Boy, which were used to strike Hiroshima and Nagasaki respectively, were atom bombs. The atom bomb is a fission bomb, meaning it relies on the power of splitting the atom. In 1952, the hydrogen bomb was developed by the United States of America. The hydrogen bomb relies on a fission reaction to create nuclear fusion. This grants far more destructive power with relatively far less radiation. By 1953, the first "dial-a-yield" nuke was invented. These nukes allow you to choose the yield of the nuke, allowing you to control its power output [1]. By 1953, America had developed a nuclear bomb that could be fired out of a 280mm artillery gun—the power of Helios locked within 28 cm [2]. By 1958, the U.S. had invented neutron bombs [3], a system capable of releasing a short-lived powerful wave of neutron and gamma radiation. This could penetrate armor or several meters of earth and would be extremely destructive to living tissue. Its purpose being discouraging an armored ground invasion of Western Europe by the Warsaw Pact. By the 1970s, America and the USSR had developed "backpack nukes," known as SADM. These are nukes that weigh a little over 20 kg and can be carried by a paratrooper, buried, then remotely detonated [4]. As early as the 1970s, America had invented MRR nukes. MRR stands for minimal residual radiation. If used in real life, these nukes (depending on yield) create fallout which produces less radiation than atom bombs and even hydrogen bombs. The residual fallout can be as minimal as only a little above background radiation levels—meaning you could get away with using an MRR without any laymen noticing, especially since nukes are usually portrayed as harbingers of Armageddon rather than the scalpels they can also be. Sources for MRR: [5][6][7][8][9]. Let's examine the conventional American strike on Iran's nuclear facilities. In an operation called "Midnight Hammer," on June 22, 2025, the United States Air Force and Navy attacked three Iranian nuclear facilities: Fordow, Natanz, and Isfahan. The stated goal being the destruction of Iran's nuclear program. For the purpose of this article, I want to focus on Fordow and the strike delivered to it. The Fordow nuclear facility is located 80 to 90 meters (260 to 295 feet) beneath solid rock inside a mountain bearing the same name. However, Rafael Grossi, Director General of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), gave an interview to the Financial Times [10] in which he stated:

“The most sensitive elements are located half a mile [800 meters] underground — I’ve been there many times. To reach them, you have to go down, down, down through a spiral tunnel.”

Additional reporting confirms Iran places key nuclear sites up to 800 meters deep [11][12][13]. For reference, the U.S. NORAD complex, a heavily fortified, Cold War-era underground nuclear bunker, is situated 600 meters below ground. It is designed to withstand a direct nuclear strike or a nearby detonation of up to 30 megatons at a distance of several kilometers [14]. U.S. President Donald J. Trump claimed:

“Monumental Damage was done to all Nuclear sites in Iran, as shown by satellite images. Obliteration is an accurate term! The white structure shown is deeply embedded into the rock, with even its roof well below ground level, and completely shielded from flame. The biggest damage took place far below ground level. Bullseye!!!”

This was somewhat contradicted by a Pentagon intelligence assessment of the attack [16]. The White House claimed that the "flat-out wrong" assessment was leaked by "a low-level loser in the intelligence community" [17]. The following is pure conjecture based on the few actual pieces of evidence we have so far. The disparity between the early intelligence assessment and claims from President Donald Trump, Secretary Hegseth, and the White House are potentially due to the nature of the Fordow nuclear facility. Rafael Grossi has made it unambiguous that the most sensitive elements are 800 meters underground. Available satellite photos show clear surface damage. The damage is possibly severe to those parts of the facility which are "only" located 80 to 90 meters underground; despite us not having evidence beyond satellite pictures of surface damage, I would argue that those parts of the facility located at a depth of 800 meters would have not been damaged by the strike. America bombed Fordow using the MOP (Massive Ordnance Penetrator)—a 30,000-lb bomb of which only an estimated 30–40 have been produced. The MOP is rated as being able to penetrate 60 meters of reinforced concrete rated at 5,000 PSI [18]. If used against reinforced concrete with a PSI rating of 10,000, the penetration depth drops to 25 feet or 7.62 meters. Now here's the issue: the Fordow mountain is a granite mountain. Granite has a PSI rating of 20,000. While the greater PSI rating of granite compared to concrete does not scale in an equivalent manner, granite is still certainly harder to penetrate than standard reinforced concrete. This means a MOP will penetrate less than 8 meters into granite. Let's, for the sake of argument, say that it is 6 meters. You'd need about 200 MOPs to smash through Fordow mountain. Then you'd need a far larger number of MOPs to actually dig under Fordow and reach the most sensitive parts of the nuclear facility. Let's suppose you only need 600 MOPs to take out the Fordow facility (it's actually over 1,000), and let's suppose America has an infinite supply of MOPs. Problem 1: At most, an estimated 40 MOPs (let's say 50) have been built. Problem 2: Only the B-2 Spirit bomber is capable of carrying the MOP, of which the United States currently fields only 19 operational aircraft (originally 21 were built; one crashed in 2008, one retired). Each bomber can carry only 2 MOPs. So you would need 19 aircraft running about 15 sorties each to take out Fordow—which is: A) Logistically and operationally impossible, as not all B-2s are operational simultaneously. B) Allows Iran the time to evacuate anything important and potentially even shoot down a precious B-2. So: what is better, cheaper, and more efficient — dropping 600 MOPs or dropping 2 MRRs? Now here's an added complication. There is a metric called CEP that measures the accuracy of guided munitions. The MOP has a CEP of less than 16 feet. Some individuals think you can "dig" toward a target using guided munitions. That is impossible. The guided munition does not have the capability to hit the same hole made by a previous bomb (unless by random chance). Even if you have the needed number of MOPs, a hundred B-2 bombers, no air defenses, no evacuation of centrifuges & fissile material — you still cannot "dig" through Fordow. Using our previous estimate of 600 MOPs (which realistically would be over 1,000), you now have to account for the Problem of CEP. Let's say that doubling the amount of MOPs is enough. You now have to drop 1,200 of them. There's another problem: matter cannot be destroyed. When a bomb is dropped on an area—even a bunker buster—the matter is not destroyed. It is shifted or transformed. A small amount of that matter will simply drop back down into the hole you just made, further increasing the amount of matter the bombs have to go through each time. Simply put, when taking all these compounding factors into consideration, destroying certain hardened targets with conventional munitions is flat-out impossible, when taking into account constraints imposed by physics, logistics, and operational capability.

To reiterate: the following is speculation on why MRRs were designed, as there is no direct evidence for it. Since it has been made clear that the below is speculation, let us proceed. The above constraints are why America (also possibly Russia and China) bothered making dial-a-yield tactical MRRs. Due to the existence of MAD, they are the only solution that is physically possible. Another possibility is a ground invasion of Iran which is problematic for the U.S. It would cause enough casualties to outrage the American public. Additionally, it would hand the Russians and the Chinese an opportunity they may choose to exploit by supplying Iran with weapons and economic aid, much like the U.S. is doing for Ukraine. Therefore, in such situations where you need to hit a high-value target and simultaneously your opponent is capable of a strategic response, an MRR might be the only system that can avoid a ground war and simultaneously potentially not trigger said response. Just to reiterate: a layman cannot tell the difference between a dial-a-yield tactical MRR and a conventional explosion. Obviously this applies strictly to laymen. In addition, if such a system is used, then both attacker and victim are incentivized to keep it a secret. "Secret" escalation can be responded to, in secret, without alarming the nation’s public. Public knowledge of the event would cause two reactions: Parts of the public might collapse in fear and demand surrender. Another segment might demand a symmetrical response. For example, if Russia gets hit with a tactical nuke by NATO (using the current government of Ukraine), Russia is incentivized to respond in kind to prevent future escalation. However, they would not acknowledge the event, as public upheaval would cause part of the Russian populace to demand surrender, while another segment demands escalation such as the usage of strategic nukes rather than "just" tactical ones. For a nation such as Iran, one can presume an increase in the number of people demanding surrender. But those demanding a strategic response would be the majority; they would demand that their government deliver strategic responses since Iran does not have nukes. The response could be: Closing the Strait of Hormuz Targeting Gulf oil infrastructure Targeting American bases in the region Three responses that, while conventional in nature, are strategic in effect. Or you would see a mass surge of Iranians demanding that Iran build its own nuclear arsenal to prevent future escalation — and demanding that Iran demonstrate the willingness to use such systems. One must wonder: in future wars, will the power of Helios be brought to bear? Or has it already come to pass?

[1] Carey Sublette, Nuclear Weapons FAQ, “First dial-a-yield” — https://nuclearweaponarchive.org/Nuclearfaq/NuclearWeaponsFAQ.html� [2] Congressional Research Service, 1953, “Atomic Artillery & Early Nuclear Guns” — https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB439/docs/doc_62.PDF� [3] Neutron bomb invention, 1958 — https://share.google/JC6vb6NIBLxCcZ1lQ� [4] SADM “backpack nukes,” 1970s — https://nuclearweaponarchive.org/Usa/Weapons/SmallNukes.html� [5] NIE 11-2-63 The Soviet Atomic Energy Program — https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/nie-11-2-63� [6] DoD/AEC handbook The Effects of Nuclear Weapons, Chapter 9 — https://www.atomicarchive.com/History/coldwar/nuclearweapons.html� [7] Carey Sublette, Nuclear Weapons FAQ “Minimum Residual Radiation (MRR) Designs” — https://nuclearweaponarchive.org/Nuclearfaq/NuclearWeaponsFAQ.html� [8] Operation Dominic, Androscoggin & Housatonic test reports — https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB439� [9] JSTOR, “The Neutron Bomb and Other New Limited-Nuclear-War Weapons” — https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2307/� [10] Financial Times interview with Rafael Grossi — https://share.google/xAz91G14rR4vawW9k� [11] Iran Places Key Nuclear Sites 800 Meters Deep — https://share.google/9dC1iYUWXeh7OYYgq� [12] IAEA's Grossi: Iran's Nuclear Facilities Buried Too Deep Underground To Be Hit By 'surgical Strike' — https://share.google/FF26knZgfnqmfJoma� [13] Trump says Putin of

正文由 探How 从来源站点 RSS 同步,内容未经改写;遇到排版缺失或需要图片、视频时请以原文为准。

打开原文
去社区讨论 →